Libertà nella natura
Abstract
The debate as to the nature of free will focused on two options: either free willruns afoul of the natural order or it is somehow compatible withsome kind of complex and articulated causal process . Both alternatives are not satisfying for a series of well known reasons. Yet, such a discussion is based on a mechanistic view of the natural world assuming that natural phenomena are reducible to local phenomena. In this paper, I will briefly summarize the recent approaches in philosophy of mind and in the neurosciences. Eventually I will introduce and criticize what could be dubbed the “problem of the instantaneous choice” – namely the idea that a free choice has to take place instantaneously. On the contrary, I will consider whether free will could be an intrinsic capacity endorsed by natural phenomena when unfolding themselves into further phenomena. To recap: free will inside the natural order, then, rather than free will versus the natural order