Journal of Medical Ethics 47 (12):e18-e18 (2021)
AbstractWe report here an emerging dispute in Italy concerning triage criteria for critically ill covid-19 patients, and how best to support doctors having to make difficult decisions in a context of insufficient life saving resources. The dispute we present is particularly significant as it juxtaposes two opposite views of who should make triage decisions, and how doctors should best be supported. There are both empirical and normative questions at stake here. The empirical questions pertain to the available level of evidence that healthcare professionals would rather not be left alone with their ‘clinical judgments’ to make triage decisions, and to the accounts of distributive justice that doctors and healthcare professionals rely on, when making triage decisions. The normative questions pertain to how this empirical evidence should inform guidelines on how prioritisation decisions are made in a context of emergency, and who gets to have the authority to do so. This debate goes beyond the discussion of the care of critically ill patients with COVID-19 and has broader implications beyond the national context for the discussion of how to relieve moral distress in contexts of imbalances between healthcare resources and clinical needs of a population.
Similar books and articles
Triage During the COVID-19 Epidemic in Spain: Better and Worse Ethical Arguments.Benjamin Herreros, Pablo Gella & Diego Real de Asua - 2020 - Journal of Medical Ethics 46 (7):455-458.
Allocation of Scarce Resources During the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Jewish Ethical Perspective.Amy Solnica, Leonid Barski & Alan Jotkowitz - 2020 - Journal of Medical Ethics 46 (7):444-446.
Medical Mismanagement or Public Vacillation?P. N. Bamford - 1981 - Journal of Medical Ethics 7 (4):179-181.
The Good, the Bad and the Ugly: Pandemic Priority Decisions and Triage.Hans Flaatten, Vernon Van Heerden, Christian Jung, Michael Beil, Susannah Leaver, Andrew Rhodes, Bertrand Guidet & Dylan W. deLange - 2021 - Journal of Medical Ethics 47 (12):e75-e75.
Courts as Communicators: Can Doctors Learn From Judges' Decisions?: The Doctor's Question: ‘Will I Be All Right If I …? [REVIEW]Loane Skene - 2004 - Journal of Bioethical Inquiry 1 (1):49-56.
Triage of Critical Care Resources in COVID-19: A Stronger Role for Justice.Lynette Reid - 2020 - Journal of Medical Ethics 46 (8):526-530.
Practising Doctors, Resource Allocation and Ethics.A. D. B. Chant - 1989 - Journal of Applied Philosophy 6 (1):71-76.
From Futility to Triage.R. A. Gatter & J. C. Moskop - 1995 - Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 20 (2):191-205.
Fragile Lives with Fragile Rights: Justice for Babies Born at the Limit of Viability.Manya J. Hendriks & John D. Lantos - 2018 - Bioethics 32 (3):205-214.
Trust and Distrust in Cpr Decisions.Barbara Hayes - 2010 - Journal of Bioethical Inquiry 7 (1):111-122.
How Do Nursing Home Doctors Involve Patients and Next of Kin in End-of-Life Decisions? A Qualitative Study From Norway.Maria Romøren, Reidar Pedersen & Reidun Førde - 2016 - BMC Medical Ethics 17 (1):1-8.
The Role of Doctors' Religious Faith and Ethnicity in Taking Ethically Controversial Decisions During End-of-Life Care.C. Seale - 2010 - Journal of Medical Ethics 36 (11):677-682.
Critical Care Ethics in Hong Kong: Cross-Cultural Conflicts as East Meets West.F. Cheng, Mary Ip, K. K. Wong & W. W. Yan - 1998 - Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 23 (6):616 – 627.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
Citations of this work
The Ethical Unjustifications of COVID-19 Triage Committees.Yi Jiao Tian - 2021 - Journal of Bioethical Inquiry 18 (4):621-628.
Deciding the Criteria Is Not Enough: Moral Issues to Consider for a Fair Allocation of Scarce ICU Resources.Davide Battisti & Mario Picozzi - 2022 - Philosophies 7 (5):92.
Operation of a triage committee for advanced life support during the COVID-19 pandemic.Benjamín Herreros, Rafael Ruiz de Luna, Natalia de la Calle, Diego Gayoso, Paula Martínez, Karmele Olaciregui Dague & Gregorio Palacios - 2022 - Philosophy, Ethics, and Humanities in Medicine 17 (1):1-8.
COVID-19 Underscores the Important Role of Clinical Ethics Committees in Africa.Adetayo Emmanuel Obasa, Anita Kleinsmidt, Siti Mukaumbya Kabanda & Keymanthri Moodley - 2021 - BMC Medical Ethics 22 (1):1-9.