The good, the bad and the ugly: pandemic priority decisions and triage
Hans Flaatten, Vernon Van Heerden, Christian Jung, Michael Beil, Susannah Leaver, Andrew Rhodes, Bertrand Guidet & Dylan W. deLange
Journal of Medical Ethics 47 (12):e75-e75 (2021)
Abstract
In this analysis we discuss the change in criteria for triage of patients during three different phases of a pandemic like COVID-19, seen from the critical care point of view. Availability of critical care beds has become a hot topic, and in many countries, we have seen a huge increase in the provision of temporary intensive care bed capacity. However, there is a limit where the hospitals may run out of resources to provide critical care, which is heavily dependent on trained staff, just-in-time supply chains for clinical consumables and drugs and advanced equipment. In the first phase, we can still do clinical prioritisation and decision-making as usual, based on the need for intensive care and prognostication: what are the odds for a good result with regard to survival and quality of life. In the next, the resources are mostly available, but the system is stressed by many patients arriving over a short time period and auxiliary beds in different places in the hospital being used. We may have to abandon admittance of patients with doubtful prognosis. In the last phase, usual medical triage and priority setting may not be sufficient to decrease inflow and there may not be enough intensive care unit beds available. In this phase different criteria must be applied using a utilitarian approach for triage. We argue that this is an important transition where society, and not physicians, must provide guidance to support triage that is no longer based on medical priorities alone.DOI
10.1136/medethics-2020-106489
My notes
Similar books and articles
Intensive care triage: Priority should be independent of whether patients are already receiving intensive care.Tony Hope, John Mcmillan & Elaine Hill - 2012 - Bioethics 26 (5):259-266.
Allocation of scarce resources during the COVID-19 pandemic: a Jewish ethical perspective.Amy Solnica, Leonid Barski & Alan Jotkowitz - 2020 - Journal of Medical Ethics 46 (7):444-446.
Paper: Enhancing the fairness of pandemic critical care triage.Jeffrey Kirby - 2010 - Journal of Medical Ethics 36 (12):758-761.
A relational analysis of pandemic critical care triage protocols.Chris Kaposy & Sarah Khraishi - 2012 - International Journal of Feminist Approaches to Bioethics 5 (1):70-90.
Critical care ethics in Hong Kong: Cross-cultural conflicts as east meets west.F. Cheng, Mary Ip, K. K. Wong & W. W. Yan - 1998 - Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 23 (6):616 – 627.
Moral principles for allocating scarce medical resources in an influenza pandemic.Marcel Verweij - 2009 - Journal of Bioethical Inquiry 6 (2):159--169.
Triage during the COVID-19 epidemic in Spain: better and worse ethical arguments.Benjamin Herreros, Pablo Gella & Diego Real de Asua - 2020 - Journal of Medical Ethics 46 (7):455-458.
ICU triage in an impending crisis: uncertainty, pre-emption and preparation.Dominic Wilkinson - 2020 - Journal of Medical Ethics 46 (5):287-288.
From Futility to Triage.R. A. Gatter & J. C. Moskop - 1995 - Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 20 (2):191-205.
Anti-theory in action? Planning for pandemics, triage and ICU or: how not to bite a bullet. [REVIEW]Nathan Emmerich - 2011 - Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 14 (1):91-100.
Respecting Disability Rights — Toward Improved Crisis Standards of Care.Michelle M. Mello, Govind Persad & Douglas B. White - 2020 - New England Journal of Medicine (5):DOI: 10.1056/NEJMp2011997.
Triage and critical care of children.Andrew Griffin & David C. Thomasma - 1983 - Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics 4 (2).
Analytics
Added to PP
2020-06-11
Downloads
18 (#614,987)
6 months
1 (#451,971)
2020-06-11
Downloads
18 (#614,987)
6 months
1 (#451,971)
Historical graph of downloads
Citations of this work
Multidisciplinary support for ethics deliberations during the first COVID wave.Bénédicte Lombart, Laura Moïsi, Valérie Bellamy, Valérie Landolfini, Marie-Josée Manifacier, Valérie Mesnage, Charlotte Heilbrunn, Dominique Pateron, Alexandra Andro-Melin, Olivier Fain, Nicolas Carbonell, Anne Bourrier, Caroline Thomas, Delphine Libeaut, Christian-Guy Coichard, Alice Polomeni & Bertrand Guidet - 2022 - Nursing Ethics 29 (4):833-843.
References found in this work
Whose life to save? Scarce resources allocation in the COVID-19 outbreak.Chiara Mannelli - 2020 - Journal of Medical Ethics 46 (6):364-366.
Triage during the COVID-19 epidemic in Spain: better and worse ethical arguments.Benjamin Herreros, Pablo Gella & Diego Real de Asua - 2020 - Journal of Medical Ethics 46 (7):455-458.