Stakeholder Dialogue as Agonistic Deliberation: Exploring the Role of Conflict and Self-Interest in Business-NGO Interaction

Business Ethics Quarterly 30 (1):3-30 (2020)
  Copy   BIBTEX

Abstract

ABSTRACT:Many companies engage in dialogue with nongovernmental organizations about societal issues. The question is what a regulative ideal for such dialogues should be. In the literature on corporate social responsibility, the Habermasian notion of communicative action is often presented as a regulative ideal for stakeholder dialogue, implying that actors should aim at consensus and set strategic considerations aside. In this article, we argue that in many cases, communicative action is not a suitable regulative ideal for dialogue between companies and NGOs. We contend that there is often an adversarial element in the relation between companies and NGOs, and that an orientation towards consensus can be in tension with this adversarial relation. We develop an alternative approach to stakeholder dialogue called ‘agonistic deliberation.’ In this approach, conflict and strategic considerations play a legitimate and, up to a certain point, desirable role.

Similar books and articles

Critical points of CSR‐related stakeholder dialogue in practice.Klement Podnar Ursa Golob - 2014 - Business Ethics, the Environment and Responsibility 23 (3):248-257.
Behind CSR: Mutual Perceptions in Multi-Stakeholder Dialogue.Daniel Arenas, Josep M. Lozano & Laura Albareda - 2007 - Proceedings of the International Association for Business and Society 18:419-424.
Critical points of CSR‐related stakeholder dialogue in practice.Ursa Golob & Klement Podnar - 2014 - Business Ethics: A European Review 23 (3):248-257.
Agonistic Pluralism and Stakeholder Engagement.Cedric Dawkins - 2015 - Business Ethics Quarterly 25 (1):1-28.
Mediation as an ethical adjunct of stakeholder theory.Marc Lampe - 2001 - Journal of Business Ethics 31 (2):165 - 173.
Communicative Action, Strategic Action, and Inter-Group Dialogue.Michael Rabinder James - 2003 - European Journal of Political Theory 2 (2):157-182.

Analytics

Added to PP
2019-09-18

Downloads
397 (#44,161)

6 months
159 (#15,276)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author Profiles

Vincent Blok
Wageningen University and Research
Marcel Verweij
Utrecht University