Multilevel Ensemble Explanations: A Case from Theoretical Biology

In this paper I will reconstruct and analyze a famous argument by Stuart Kauffman about complex systems and evolution, in order to highlight the use in theoretical biology of a kind of non-mechanistic and non-causal explanation which I propose to call, following Kauffman, ensemble explanation. The aim is to contribute to the ongoing philosophical debate about non-causal explanations in the special sciences, kinds of explanation apparently extraneous to the received causal-mechanistic view. Ensemble explanations resemble quite closely the explanations of the structural kind proposed by Philippe Huneman, which—unlike mechanistic explanations—do not explain by exposing the causal structure of a phenomenon, but...