Health Care Analysis 14 (3):157-168 (2006)
AbstractModern health care rhetoric promotes choice and individual patient rights as dominant values. Yet we also accept that in any regime constrained by finite resources, difficult choices between patients are inevitable. How can we balance rights to liberty, on the one hand, with equity in the allocation of scarce resources on the other? For example, the duty of health authorities to allocate resources is a duty owed to the community as a whole, rather than to specific individuals. Macro-duties of this nature are founded on the notion of equity and fairness amongst individuals rather than personal liberty. They presume that if hard choices have to be made, they will be resolved according to fair and consistent principles which treat equal cases equally, and unequal cases unequally.In this paper, we argue for greater clarity and candour in the health care rights debate. With this in mind, we discuss (1) private and public rights, (2) negative and positive rights, (3) procedural and substantive rights, (4) sustainable health care rights and (5) the New Zealand booking system for prioritising access to elective services. This system aims to consider: individual need and ability to benefit alongside the resources made available to elective health services in an attempt to give the principles of equity practical effect. We describe a continuum on which the merits of those, sometimes competing, values—liberty and equity—can be evaluated and assessed
Similar books and articles
Equity and resource allocation in health care: Dialogue between Islam and Christianity.Christoph Benn & Adnan A. Hyder - 2002 - Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 5 (2):181-189.
Free choice, equity, and care: The moral foundations of health care.Chan Ho-mun - 1999 - Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 24 (6):624 – 637.
Is There a Human Right to Private Health Care?Aeyal Gross - 2013 - Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics 41 (1):138-146.
Globalization, human rights, and the social determinants of health.Audrey R. Chapman - 2009 - Bioethics 23 (2):97-111.
Health Care: A Brave New World.Shelley Morrisette, William D. Oberman, Allison D. Watts & Joseph B. Beck - 2015 - Health Care Analysis 23 (1):88-105.
Equitable rationing of highly specialised health care services for children: a perspective from South Africa.W. A. Landman & L. D. Henley - 1999 - Journal of Medical Ethics 25 (3):224-229.
Equity in Health Care from a Communitarian Standpoint.Megan Black & Gavin Mooney - 2002 - Health Care Analysis 10 (2):193-208.
Vertical Equity in Health Care Resource Allocation.Gavin Mooney - 2000 - Health Care Analysis 8 (3):203-215.
Is there a right to health?Timothy Goodman - 2005 - Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 30 (6):643 – 662.
Is there a right to health?Timothy Goodman 1 - 2005 - Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 30 (6):643-662.
Trust is Not Enough: Bringing Human Rights to Medicine.David J. Rothman - 2006 - New York Review Books.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
Citations of this work
Why Bariatric Surgery Should be Given High Priority: An Argument from Law and Morality.Karl Persson - 2014 - Health Care Analysis 22 (4):305-324.
References found in this work
Beyond health outcomes: The benefits of health care. [REVIEW]Gavin Mooney - 1998 - Health Care Analysis 6 (2):99-105.
Beyond health outcomes: the benefits of health care.Gavin Mooney - 1998 - Health Care Analysis 6 (2):99-105.