Philosophical Papers 36 (2):245-270 (2007)
AbstractThis article treats recent bioethical discussions of double effect reasoning (DER), offering a summary account of DER and construing it as rooted in a sensible view of what is central to someone's identity as a moral agent. It then treats objections raised in recent years by Judith Thomson, Alison McIntyre, and Frances Kamm against familiar ways of applying DER to certain controversies within medical ethics, especially, that over physician-assisted suicide. After detailing, interpreting, and attempting to rebut the challenges from these philosophers, who are especially interesting because their criticisms of DER come from allies in DER's struggle against consequentialist reasoning, the essay engages DER's contribution to a recent dispute over treatment of patients in what is called ‘persistent vegetative state.' Near its end, the paper sketches several possible points of entry to DER and sources of justification for it. The essay concludes by indicating a connection between these paths and its opening idea of moral identity
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
References found in this work
The Sanctity-of-Life Doctrine in Medicine: A Critique.Helga Kuhse - 1987 - Oxford University Press.
Citations of this work
Life and Health: A Value in Itself for Human Beings?Helen Watt - 2015 - HEC Forum 27 (3):207-228.
Knowing, Anticipating, Even Facilitating but Still Not Intending: Another Challenge to Double Effect Reasoning.S. Duckett - 2018 - Journal of Bioethical Inquiry 15 (1):33-37.
The Medical Exception to the Prohibition of Killing: A Matter of the Right Intention?Govert Den Hartogh - 2019 - Ratio Juris 32 (2):157-176.
Similar books and articles
Four Versions of Double Effect.Donald B. Marquis - 1991 - Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 16 (5):515-544.
Double-Effect Reasoning: Doing Good and Avoiding Evil.T. A. Cavanaugh - 2006 - Oxford University Press.
Who is Entitled to Double Effect?Joseph Boyle - 1991 - Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 16 (5):475-494.
The Paradox of Self-Defense: Saving Oneself by Harming Another.Whitley R. P. Kaufman - 2009 - Lexington Books.
The Role of the Principle of Double Effect in Ethics Education at US Medical Schools and its Potential Impact on Pain Management at the End of Life.Robert Macauley - 2012 - Journal of Medical Ethics 38 (3):174-178.
Two Challenges to the Double Effect Doctrine: Euthanasia and Abortion.A. B. Shaw - 2002 - Journal of Medical Ethics 28 (2):102-104.
Double Effect: A Useful Rule That Alone Cannot Justify Hastening Death.J. A. Billings - 2011 - Journal of Medical Ethics 37 (7):437-440.
Double-Effect Reasoning and the Conception of Human Embryos.Timothy F. Murphy - 2013 - Journal of Medical Ethics 39 (8):529-532.
Intention and Responsibility in Double Effect Cases.David K. Chan - 2000 - Ethical Theory and Moral Practice 3 (4):405-434.
Covert Video Surveillance and the Principle of Double Effect: A Response to Criticism.E. A. Shinebourne - 1996 - Journal of Medical Ethics 22 (1):26-31.