Continental Philosophy Review 43 (2):241-265 (2010)
AbstractOne unresolved dispute within Heidegger scholarship concerns the question of whether Dasein should be conceived in terms of narrative self-constitution. A survey of the current literature suggests two standard responses. The first correlates Heidegger’s talk of authentic historicality with that of self-authorship. To the alternative perspective, however, Heidegger’s talk of Dasein’s existentiality, with its emphasis on nullity and unattainability, is taken as evidence that Dasein is structurally and ontologically incapable of being completed via any life-project. Narrativity imports into Being and Time commitments concerning temporality, selfhood, and ethics, which Heidegger rejects. Although both positions find good exegetic support for their conclusions, they can’t both be right. In this article, I navigate a path between these two irreconcilable positions by applying insights derived from recent debates within Anglo-American literature on personal identity. I develop an alternative thesis to Narrativism, without rejecting it outright, by arguing that Dasein can be analysed in terms of what I call narratability conditions. These allow us to make sense of the prima facie paradoxical notion of historicality without narrativity. Indeed, rather than reconciling the two standard positions, I hold that the tension between them says something important about Dasein’s kind of existence. Thus I conclude that while the narrativist question Who ought I to be? is perfectly legitimate within limits, what the existential analysis of the limits on narratability reveals is that no answer to this question can ever be definitive
Similar books and articles
The Origin of the Work of Art: Historicality, Temporality, and Destiny in Heidegger's Philosophy of the 1930s.James Magrini - unknown
The Heidegger-Buber Controversy: The Status of the I-Thou.Ḥayim Gordon - 2001 - Greenwood Press.
The Self as Resolution: Heidegger, Derrida and the Intimacy of the Question of the Meaning of Being.John Russon - 2008 - Research in Phenomenology 38 (1):90-110.
Toward a Metaphysical Freedom: Heidegger’s Project of a Metaphysics of Dasein.François Jaran - 2010 - International Journal of Philosophical Studies 18 (2):205-227.
Heidegger and Dasein’s ‘Bodily Nature’: What is the Hidden Problematic?David R. Cerbone - 2000 - International Journal of Philosophical Studies 8 (2):209 – 230.
Heidegger and the Problem of Idealism.Piotr Hoffman - 2000 - Inquiry: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Philosophy 43 (4):403 – 411.
Gender and Time: Revisiting the Question of Dasein’s Neutrality.Kevin Aho - 2007 - Epoché: A Journal for the History of Philosophy 12 (1):137-155.
When Conscience Calls, Will Dasein Answer? Heideggerian Authenticity and the Possibility of Ethical Life.Mariana Ortega - 2005 - International Journal of Philosophical Studies 13 (1):15 – 34.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
Citations of this work
Narrative and Embodiment – a Scalar Approach.Allan Køster - 2017 - Phenomenology and the Cognitive Sciences 16 (5):893-908.
Body and Self: An Entangled Narrative.Priscilla Brandon - 2016 - Phenomenology and the Cognitive Sciences 15 (1):67-83.
Reading From the Middle: Heidegger and the Narrative Self.Ben Roth - 2018 - European Journal of Philosophy 26 (2):746-762.
Heidegger and the Supposed Meaninglessness of Personal Immortality.Adam Buben - 2016 - Journal of the American Philosophical Association 2 (3):384-399.
On a Judgment of One’s Own: Heideggerian Authenticity, Standpoints, and All Things Considered.Denis McManus - 2019 - Mind 128 (512):1181-1204.
References found in this work
A Treatise of Human Nature: Being an Attempt to Introduce the Experimental Method of Reasoning Into Moral Subjects.David Hume & D. G. C. Macnabb (eds.) - 1738 - Collins.
Sources of the Self: The Making of the Modern Identity.Charles Taylor - 1989 - Harvard University Press.