Apollonius Dyscolus and the ambiguity of ambiguity

Classical Quarterly 45 (2):441-473 (1995)
  Copy   BIBTEX


Apollonius Dyscolus’ use of ambiguity in grammatical problem-solving has in recent years had the benefit of two scholarly studies. David Blank, in the course of his analysis of the Syntax as a whole, has described the broad functions which Apollonius assigns to ambiguity. Jean Lallot's 1988 paper, ‘Apollonius Dyscole et l'ambigüité linguistique: problemes et solutions’, is devoted exclusively to the treatment of linguistic ambiguity in Apollonius’ work. Yet it is to be feared that the flood of light thrown by these scholars on what had been an unregarded corner of ancient grammar has shown up rather more than Apollonius would have cared to admit, both about the nature, and about the prospects for success, of the enterprise on which he was engaged. At the same time, certain structural features of ancient grammar, at least of the ancient grammar which Apollonius himself constructed, have come into sharper focus: features clear enough with the benefit of hindsight, but glimpsed, it appears, all too dimly by Apollonius himslf. It is now worryingly clear not only that ambiguity was ambiguous for Apollonius, but also that the ambiguity of ambiguity represented a genuine threat to the coherence and value of his work. In this paper I set out to justify both these claims.

Similar books and articles

Ancient Philosophy and Grammar. [REVIEW]Daniel J. Taylor - 1986 - Ancient Philosophy 6:245-251.
Ambiguity in Architecture.Christoph Baumberger - 2009 - In G. Ernst, O. Scholz & J. Steinbrenner (eds.), Nelson Goodman: From Logic to Art. Ontos. pp. 293--319.
Jaffray’s ideas on ambiguity.Peter P. Wakker - 2011 - Theory and Decision 71 (1):11-22.
Apollonius of Tyana, and other essays.Thomas Whittaker - 1906 - London,: S. Sonnenschein & co., lim..
Questions without Answers.E. Lobel - 1928 - Classical Quarterly 22 (2):115-116.
'Analogy, Anomaly and Apollonius Dyscolus.David Blank - 1994 - In Stephen Everson (ed.), Language. Cambridge University Press. pp. 149--165.
Apollonius of Tyana, and Other Essays. [REVIEW]G. J. Blewett - 1907 - Philosophical Review 16 (4):442-445.
Further Notes on Apollonius Rhodius.M. Campbell - 1971 - Classical Quarterly 21 (02):402-.


Added to PP

611 (#29,013)

6 months
160 (#20,692)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author's Profile

Catherine Atherton
University of California, Los Angeles

Citations of this work

No citations found.

Add more citations

References found in this work

Les Stoïciens et leur logique.[author unknown] - 1980 - Revue de Métaphysique et de Morale 85 (4):562-563.
The Stoics on Ambiguity. [REVIEW]David Blank & Catherine Atherton - 1995 - Philosophical Review 104 (2):267.

Add more references