Ethics and International Affairs 31 (4):479-493 (2017)
AbstractIn the rapidly expanding literature on the ethics of climate engineering, a lot has been made of the fact that stratospheric aerosol injection would for the first time create a world whose climate had been intentionally shaped by deliberate human decisions. Intention has always mattered in ethics. Due to the importance of intention in assigning culpability for harms, one might expect that the moral responsibility for any harms created during an attempt to reconstruct the global climate using stratospheric aerosols would be considerable. This article investigates such an expectation by making a comparison between the culpability for any unintended harms resulting from stratospheric aerosol injection and culpability for the unintended harms already taking place due to carbon emissions. To make this comparison, both types of unintended harms are viewed through the lens of the doctrine of double effect. The conclusion reached goes against what many might expect. The article closes by suggesting that a good way to read this surprising conclusion is that it points toward the continuing moral importance of prioritizing emission reductions.
Similar books and articles
Individual Responsibility for Carbon Emissions: Is There Anything Wrong with Overdetermining Harm?Christian Barry & Gerhard Øverland - 2015 - In Jeremy Moss (ed.), Climate Change and Justice. Cambridge University Press.
Double Counting in Supply Chain Carbon Footprinting.F. Caro, C. J. Corbett, T. Tan & R. Zuidwijk - unknown
Future Harms and Current Offspring.Jason Kawall - 2011 - Ethics, Policy and Environment 14 (1):23-26.
Emissions Trading Ethics.Jo Dirix, Wouter Peeters & Sigrid Sterckx - 2016 - Ethics, Policy and Environment 19 (1):60-75.
Carbon Trading: Unethical, Unjust and Ineffective?Simon Caney - 2011 - Royal Institute of Philosophy Supplement 69:201-234.
An Analytical Comparison of Various Influential Models of China’s Future Greenhouse Gas Emissions and Global Role.Yin Le & Yu Jie - 2013 - Theoretical Inquiries in Law 14 (1):125-150.
National Greenhouse-Gas Accounting for Effective Climate Policy on International Trade.Astrid Kander, Magnus Jiborn, Daniel Moran & Thomas Wiedmann - 2015 - Nature Climate Change 5 (5):431-435.
Moving Toward a Consensus on Climate Policy: The Essential Role of Global Public Disclosure.David Wheeler - manuscript
Unilateral Carbon Taxes, Border Tax Adjustments and Carbon Leakage.David Weisbach, Todd Munson, Gita Khun Jush, Sam Kortum, Ian Foster & Joshua Elliott - 2013 - Theoretical Inquiries in Law 14 (1):207-244.
Compensating Wrongless Historical Emissions of Grennhouse Gases.L. H. Meyer - 2004 - Ethical Perspectives 11 (1):20-35.
Consequentialism, Climate Harm and Individual Obligations.Christopher Morgan-Knapp & Charles Goodman - 2015 - Ethical Theory and Moral Practice 18 (1):177-190.
Examining the Role of Carbon Capture and Storage Through an Ethical Lens.Fabien Medvecky, Justine Lacey & Peta Ashworth - 2014 - Science and Engineering Ethics 20 (4):1-18.
Buying Low, Flying High: Carbon Offsets and Partial Compliance.Kai Spiekermann - 2014 - Political Studies 62 (4):913-929.
Reducing Carbon Emissions Worldwide: MNCs and Global Environmental Performance.Frederik Dahlmann & Stephen Brammer - 2013 - Proceedings of the International Association for Business and Society 24:144-152.
Transformations in Brazilian Deforestation and Climate Policy Since 2005.Eduardo Viola - 2013 - Theoretical Inquiries in Law 14 (1):109-124.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
Citations of this work
The Ethics of Geoengineering: A Literature Review.Augustine Pamplany, Bert Gordijn & Patrick Brereton - 2020 - Science and Engineering Ethics 26 (6):3069-3119.
The Most Good We Can Do or the Best Person We Can Be?Michel Bourban & Lisa Broussois - 2020 - Ethics, Policy and Environment 23 (2):159-179.
The Need for Governance of Climate Geoengineering.Janos Pasztor - 2017 - Ethics and International Affairs 31 (4):419-430.
References found in this work
Actions, Intentions, and Consequences: The Doctrine of Double Effect.Warren S. Quinn - 1989 - Philosophy and Public Affairs 18 (4):334-351.
How Harmful Are the Average American's Greenhouse Gas Emissions?John Nolt - 2011 - Ethics, Policy and Environment 14 (1):3-10.
Virtues and Vices and Other Essays in Moral Philosophy.Philippa Foot, James D. Wallace & Arthur Flemming - 1980 - Ethics 90 (4):587-595.