Critical Inquiry 18 (1):140-153 (1991)
AbstractThe problem that confronts us when we try to compare the structure of discourse and explanation in different domains of knowledge is that no one is an insider in more than one field, and insider information is essential. An observer who is not immersed in the practice of a particular scholarship and who wants to understand it is at the mercy of the practitioners. Yet those practitioners are themselves mystified by a largely unexamined communal myth of how scholarship is carried on. R. G. Collingwood, although primarily a philosopher, was immersed in the community of historians and understood how history is done, so that he has had an immense influence on our ideas about historiography. Every historian knows The Idea of History.1 He was also a metaphysician, yet his influence on scientists’ understanding of nature, and of science, has been nil, and it is a rare scientist indeed who has ever heard of Collingwood or read The Idea of Nature.2 Collingwood’s views of the structure of science had to be constructed in large part from the elaborate fictions created by scientists and by an earlier generation of philosophers and historians of science who participated in the Baconian myth of the hypothetical-deductive scheme. 1. See R. G. Collingwood, The Idea of History .2. See Collingwood, The Idea of Nature . R. C. Lewontin is Alexander Agassiz Professor at Harvard University. He is an experimental and theoretical evolutionary geneticist who has also worked extensively on epistemological issues in biology. He is the author of The Genetic Basis of Evolutionary Change and, with Richard Levins, of The Dialectical Biologist . His current research concerns the nature of genetic variation among individuals within species
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
Similar books and articles
Factitious Illness: An Exploration in Ethics.Neal Jay Meropol, Charles V. Ford & Richard M. Zaner - 1985 - Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 28 (2):269-281.
Can There Be Brute, Contingent Moral Facts.John H. Dreher - 2002 - Philosophical Studies 108 (1-2):23 - 30.
The Impact of Factitious Disorder on the Physician-Patient Relationship. An Epistemological Model.Christina M. van der Feltz-Cornelis - 2002 - Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 5 (3):253-261.
The Origins of Factitious Disorder.Richard A. A. Kanaan & Simon C. Wessely - 2010 - History of the Human Sciences 23 (2):68-85.
Social Facts and Psychological Facts.David Papineau - 1985 - In Gregory Currie & A. Musgrave (eds.), Popper and the Human Sciences. Martinus Nijhoff. pp. 43-52.
La Subjetividad En Las Ciencias Sociales, Una Cuestión Ontológica y No Epistemológica.Jorge Gregorio Posada - 2006 - Cinta de Moebio 25.
The Innate Schema of Natural Numbers Does Not Explain Historical, Cultural, and Developmental Differences.Marie-Pascale Noël, Jacques Grégoire, Gaëlle Meert & Xavier Seron - 2008 - Behavioral and Brain Sciences 31 (6):664-665.
Rights, Moral Values and Natural Facts: A Reply to Mary Midgley on the Problem of Child-Abuse.David Archard - 1992 - Journal of Applied Philosophy 9 (1):99-104.
Intentionalistic Explanations in the Social Sciences.John R. Searle - 1991 - Philosophy of the Social Sciences 21 (3):332-344.
The Religious, the Secular, and the Natural Sciences: Nietzsche and the Death of God.Avron Kulak - 2011 - The European Legacy 16 (6):785 - 797.
Epistemic Norms and Natural Facts.C. S. Jenkins - 2007 - American Philosophical Quarterly 44 (3):259 - 272.
There Are Facts…and Then There Are Facts Reply to Moss and Tyler.B. Mahon - 2003 - Trends in Cognitive Sciences 7 (11):481-482.
References found in this work
No references found.
Citations of this work
A Brief (Hi)Story of Just-So Stories in Evolutionary Science.Michal Hubálek - 2020 - Philosophy of the Social Sciences 51 (5):447-468.
Transformation of the Human Image in the Paradigm of Knowledge Evolution.V. H. Kremen & V. V. Ilin - 2021 - Anthropological Measurements of Philosophical Research 19:5-14.
Metabolic Rift or Metabolic Shift? Dialectics, Nature, and the World-Historical Method.Jason W. Moore - 2017 - Theory and Society 46 (4):285-318.
Maynard Smith, Optimization, and Evolution.Sahotra Sarkar - 2005 - Biology and Philosophy 20 (5):951-966.
A Piecewise Aggregation of Philosophers’ and Biologists’ Perspectives: William C. Wimsatt: Re-Engineering Philosophy for Limited Beings: Piecewise Approximations to Reality; Harvard University Press, Cambridge, 2007, 472 Pp., $65.50 Hbk, ISBN 978-0-674-01545-6.Werner Callebaut, Martin Schlumpp, Julia Lang, Christoph Frischer, Stephan Handschuh, Miles MacLeod & Isabella Sarto-Jackson - 2016 - Biological Theory 11 (1):1-10.