Medical AI and human dignity: Contrasting perceptions of human and artificially intelligent (AI) decision making in diagnostic and medical resource allocation contexts

Computers in Human Behaviour 133 (2022)
  Copy   BIBTEX

Abstract

Forms of Artificial Intelligence (AI) are already being deployed into clinical settings and research into its future healthcare uses is accelerating. Despite this trajectory, more research is needed regarding the impacts on patients of increasing AI decision making. In particular, the impersonal nature of AI means that its deployment in highly sensitive contexts-of-use, such as in healthcare, raises issues associated with patients’ perceptions of (un) dignified treatment. We explore this issue through an experimental vignette study comparing individuals’ perceptions of being treated in a dignified and respectful way in various healthcare decision contexts. Participants were subject to a 2 (human or AI decision maker) x 2 (positive or negative decision outcome) x 2 (diagnostic or resource allocation healthcare scenario) factorial design. We found evidence of a “human bias” (i.e., a preference for human over AI decision makers) and an “outcome bias” (i.e., a preference for positive over negative outcomes). However, we found that for perceptions of respectful and dignified interpersonal treatment, it matters more who makes the decisions in diagnostic cases and it matters more what the outcomes are for resource allocation cases. We also found that humans were consistently viewed as appropriate decision makers and AI was viewed as dehumanizing, and that participants perceived they were treated better when subject to diagnostic as opposed to resource allocation decisions. Thematic coding of open-ended text responses supported these results. We also outline the theoretical and practical implications of these findings.

Links

PhilArchive

External links

Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server

Through your library

Similar books and articles

Kant on the Ground of Human Dignity.Apaar Kumar - forthcoming - Kantian Review:1-19.
Dignity and technology.Zbigniew Szawarski - 1989 - Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 14 (3):243-249.
Grenzen des medizinischen Fortschritts aus ethischer Sicht.Wolfgang Huber - 1994 - Zeitschrift Für Evangelische Ethik 38 (1):41-53.
Human Dignity in Portugal.João Carlos Loureiro - 2019 - In Paolo Becchi & Klaus Mathis (eds.), Handbook of Human Dignity in Europe. Springer Verlag. pp. 719-744.
Selbstachtung und Menschenwürde.Ralf Stoecker - 2004 - Studia Philosophica 63:107-120.
Birth with dignity from the Confucian perspective.Jianhui Li & Yaming Li - 2018 - Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics 39 (5):375-388.

Analytics

Added to PP
2022-05-23

Downloads
254 (#75,852)

6 months
98 (#39,246)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author Profiles

Paul Formosa
Macquarie University
Wendy A. Rogers
Macquarie University

Citations of this work

No citations found.

Add more citations