The Body in Jesus’ Tomb as a Hylemorphic Puzzle: a Response to Jaeger and Sienkiewicz and an Application for Christological Anthropology
Perichoresis 19 (2):83-97 (2021)
AbstractIn a recent paper, Andrew Jaeger and Jeremy Sienkiewicz attempt to provide an answer consistent with Thomistic hylemorphism for the following question: what was the ontological status of Christ’s dead body? Answering this question has christological anthropological import: whatever one says about Christ’s dead body, has implications for what one can say about any human’s dead body. Jaeger and Sienkiewicz answer the question this way: that Jesus’ corpse was prime matter lacking a substantial form; that it was existing form-less matter. I argue that their argument for this answer is unsound. I say, given Thomistic hylemorphism, there was no human body in Jesus’s tomb between his death and resurrection. Once I show their argument to be unsound, I provide a christological anthropological upshot: since there was no human body in Christ’s tomb, there are no human bodies in any tomb.
Similar books and articles
Dyologie; Oder, Die Lehre von den Zweierlei Menschen, von L. Sienkiewicz Und T. Vortmann-Sienkiewicz.Leonore Sienkiewicz & Thusnelde Vortmann-Sienkiewicz - 1905
A New Natural Interpretation of the Empty Tomb.Leonard Eisenberg - 2016 - International Journal for Philosophy of Religion 80 (2):133-143.
The Resurrection of Jesus and Rational Apologetics.Dale C. Allison - 2008 - Philosophia Christi 10 (2):315-335.
Matter Without Form: The Ontological Status of Christ's Dead Body.Andrew J. Jaeger & Jeremy Sienkiewicz - 2018 - Journal of Analytic Theology 6:131-145.
Hylemorphic Animalism and the Incarnational Problem of Identity.Andrew Jaeger - 2017 - Journal of Analytic Theology 5:145-162.
Dale Allison on Jesus’s Empty Tomb, His Postmortem Appearances, and the Origin of the Disciples’ Belief in His Resurrection.William Lane Craig - 2008 - Philosophia Christi 10 (2):293-301.
Replies to Evan Fales: On the Empty Tomb of Jesus.William Lane Craig - 2001 - Philosophia Christi 3 (1):67 - 76.
Hylemorphism, Rigid Designators, and the Disembodied "Jesus": A Call for Clarification.James T. Turner - 2019 - Religious Studies:1-16.
Five Modes of Scepticism: Sextus Empiricus and the Agrippan Modes.Stefan Sienkiewicz - 2019 - New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
Did Jesus Need the Spirit? An Appeal for Pneumatic Christology to Inform Christological Anthropology.Christa L. Mckirland - 2021 - Perichoresis 19 (2):43-61.
A Puzzle About the Agnostic Response to Peer Disagreement.Michele Palmira - 2013 - Philosophia 41 (4):1253-1261.
A Discussion of the Composition Dates of the Various Guodian Chu Slip Texts and Their Background: With a Discussion on the Dating of the Guodian and Baoshan Tombs.Wang Baoxuan - 2000 - Contemporary Chinese Thought 32 (1):18-42.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
Citations of this work
No citations found.
References found in this work
Aquinas’s Ontology of the Material World: Change, Hylomorphism, and Material Objects.Jeffrey E. Brower - 2014 - Oxford University Press.
There Must Be A First: Why Thomas Aquinas Rejects Infinite, Essentially Ordered, Causal Series.Caleb Cohoe - 2013 - British Journal for the History of Philosophy 21 (5):838 - 856.