On Rereading Snow

Common Knowledge 29 (3):396-397 (2023)
  Copy   BIBTEX

Abstract

When I first read Snow, I was deeply conscious, page by page, of its enormously dense character. It was clear from the outset that this novel was much more than the account of a Westernized Turkish journalist's failed attempt to cover a suicide wave among young girls in the provincial Turkish city of Kars. Almost from the start, the multidimensional narrative about Turkish youth weaved together all sorts of strains of political, religious, and social conflicts in a drama about coming of age in a land whose culture is never far from that of Europe and vice versa. Here was an incredibly sensitive effort to probe the social dynamics of a culture that was scarcely understood in Europe (and scarcely understood at home).Having finished the novel's four hundred and some pages, I was deeply impressed with what I had read but depressed by how little of what I had read I was in a position to comprehend; it was simply too richly detailed and nuanced for me to digest. Too much was going on. For days, if not weeks, after having put Snow down, my mind would drift back to the novel, alighting on a theme or a character from the novel that had left me wondering and moved me further to ponder its meaning. The subtlety that went into writing the book, the confusions implicit in the strivings of its characters, and the consequent hopelessness of their situations hit me like a ton of bricks. In a way that was difficult to articulate, I could experience something of the hopes, fears, and confusions that ran through the minds of those characters. The vicarious experience of a culture that was at once familiar and deeply alien, the comprehension of which was imperative to European society, was powerfully and skillfully expressed without being trumpeted. Thus it was impossible to forget things that did not enter directly into the story but were nevertheless clearly insinuated in the narrative: for example, the continual reference to things Armenian in a place from which Armenians had long since disappeared—but above all the snow, falling silently and gently, scarcely observed by the protagonists, on nearly every page, without ever having the slightest impact on the narrative. The continual dusting of snow on all sorts of scenes, violent, touching, amusing, intriguing, lent the story an almost eerie poetic quality that only a master storyteller could weave into sadness and tragedy (Is this an allusion to Joyce's “The Dead”?). It was clear that one reading would not suffice for me to absorb the content of this novel.About a year later, I decided to tackle the book once again in the hope of obtaining a more ordered sense of the personalities and situations it presents. This time, it was clear that reading the book was of necessity a systematic project. So I decided to read it chapter by chapter, daily, in order to “live” with it. That procedure considerably enhanced the enjoyment involved in the act of reading, but in the end I scarcely grasped much more than I had done originally. When I was finished, I was satisfied with myself for having fulfilled a demanding task, but my lack of further enlightenment on turning the last page left me almost as unsatisfied as I had been the first time. It was not that I had failed to deepen my understanding of difficult and confusing themes that were crucial to comprehending European problems. Still, I was not less aware than after my first reading of the work that much of the Turkish experience described in it was eluding me—so much so that it would be worth my while to pick up Snow a third time. Need I say more?

Links

PhilArchive



    Upload a copy of this work     Papers currently archived: 92,907

External links

Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server

Through your library

Similar books and articles

Who Was Plato?Danielle S. Allen - 2012-12-10 - In Neville Morley (ed.), Why Plato Wrote. Blackwell. pp. 9–15.
Some keys to rereading authority.Edgar Straehle - 2015 - Las Torres de Lucca: Revista Internacional de Filosofía Política 4 (7):171-207.
Read the fable - A Review of "Rereading Stones' first chapter," read>.Hanliang Zhang - 2005 - Chinese Literature and Philosophy of Communication 15 (4):9-12.
Rereading Kant on immortality and the highest good.Michael R. Morgan - 2021 - European Journal of Philosophy 30 (2):808-822.
Read and reread the reading - Overall "Rereading Stones". Minford & Huiying Yushu - 2005 - Chinese Literature and Philosophy of Communication 15 (4):41-54.
Rereading Xenophon’s Cyropaedia.William H. F. Altman - 2022 - Ancient Philosophy 42 (2):335-352.

Analytics

Added to PP
2024-05-17

Downloads
2 (#1,815,597)

6 months
2 (#1,250,897)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author's Profile

Allan Janik
University of Innsbruck

Citations of this work

No citations found.

Add more citations

References found in this work

No references found.

Add more references