Was evolution the only possible way for God to make autonomous creatures? Examination of an argument in evolutionary theodicy
International Journal for Philosophy of Religion 77 (1):37-51 (2015)
AbstractEvolutionary theodicies are attempts to explain how the enormous amounts of suffering, premature death and extinction inherent in the evolutionary process can be reconciled with belief in a loving and almighty God. A common strategy in this area is to argue that certain very valuable creaturely attributes could only be exemplified by creatures that are produced by a partly random and uncontrolled process of evolution. Evolution, in other words, was the only possible way for God to create these kinds of creatures. This article presents and examines two versions of the “only way”-argument. The anthropocentric version tries to justify God’s use of evolution by reference to the value of human freedom, and argues that freedom presupposes that God lets go of full control over the process of creation . The non-anthropocentric version presents a similar argument with respect to more inclusive creaturely properties, such as that of being “truly other” than God, or of being a “creaturely self” with a certain degree of autonomy in relation to God . With the help of a number of thought-experiments of the “Twin-Earth”-type, the author argues that both the anthropocentric and the non-anthropocentric only way-arguments fail
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
References found in this work
The Meaning of 'Meaning'.Hillary Putnam - 1975 - Minnesota Studies in the Philosophy of Science 7:131-193.
Knowing One’s Own Mind.Donald Davidson - 1987 - Proceedings and Addresses of the American Philosophical Association 60 (3):441-458.
Citations of this work
Similar books and articles
Animal Suffering, Evolution, and the Origins of Evil: Toward a “Free Creatures” Defense.Joshua M. Moritz - 2014 - Zygon 49 (2):348-380.
Re-Reading Genesis, John, and Job: A Christian Response to Darwinism.Christopher Southgate - 2011 - Zygon 46 (2):370-395.
Divine Freedom and Creaturely Suffering in Process Theology: A Critical Appraisal.Andrei A. Buckareff - 2000 - Sophia 39 (2):56-69.
Theodicy.Daniel Howard-Snyder - 2008 - In Kelly Clark (ed.), Readings in the Philosophy of Religion. Broadview.
God and Evolutionary Evil: Theodicy in the Light of Darwinism.Southgate Christopher - 2002 - Zygon 37 (4):803-824.
Constructing a Theology of Evolution: Building on John Haught.Ted Peters - 2010 - Zygon 45 (4):921-937.
Animals and the Problem of Evil in Recent Theodicies.Mark Maller - 2009 - Sophia 48 (3):299-317.
Evolution as a Cognition Process: Towards an Evolutionary Epistemology. [REVIEW]Franz M. Wuketits - 1986 - Biology and Philosophy 1 (2):191-206.
Is the Evolutionary Process Deterministic or Indeterministic? An Argument for Agnosticism.Roberta L. Millstein - 2000