Zygon 25 (3):309-316 (
1990)
Copy
BIBTEX
Abstract
In this review of papers by E. O. Wilson, Philip Gorski, and Robert Segal, I apply Wilson's description of the relations between a discipline and its antidiscipline (the science just below it in the hierarchy of sciences) to the relations between theology and the social sciences. I claim (contra Gorski) that a common methodology is applicable to natural science, social science, and theology. However, despite the fact that a discipline cannot ordinarily be reduced to its antidiscipline, I claim (with Segal) that it remains to be shown that a theistic interpretation of religious phenomena is superior to a socialāscientific explanation. I see this as work to be done rather than an impossibility. Insofar as it is shown that theology cannot be reduced to socialāscientific explanations, support is provided for the hypothesis of the existence of God.