Abstract

This chapter examines Mill's remarks on the nature and value of virtue in Utilitarianism, before looking at where virtue fits in Mill's moral philosophy. The objection that utilitarians fail to do justice to virtue, and to the value of virtue in particular, is one of the two objections to utilitarianism that Mill takes most seriously (the other being that utilitarianism cannot give an adequate account of justice). Mill draws fine‐grained distinctions amongst virtues and vices, classifying traits of character not only according to whom they benefit, but also according to the different reactions by which such traits are appropriately encouraged or discouraged. A full appreciation of Mill's views on virtue requires noting three strikingly distinctive features of his general understanding of character and its worth: the value of individuality, the malleability of human character and the relativity of virtue.