Classical Quarterly 44 (02):534- (1994)
AbstractThe treatment of the goatherd Melanthius in these lines received remarkably little animadversion from earlier commentators . In contrast, the late Manuel Fernandez-Galiano devoted an extremely full note to the passage. One may wonder, however, whether he was right to base it on the automatic assumption that what we have depicted here is an act of murder. He himself admits that we are not ‘told exactly at what moment the unfortunate Melanthius dies’. :πότομος ατη κα δεινοτάτη ποιν, ξ ς εκς κα θανεν τν Μελάνθιον, ε κα ποιητς κα ατ σιγι. Such lack of specificness would be most unlike Homer, and the removal of hands, feet, ears, nose and genitalia would be a remarkably laborious and uneconomical mode of instantly killing someone. Since we are not told that Melanthius dies I infer that he did not, any more than Eurytion did at Od. 21.300–2, in similarly trying circumstances: ‘they cut off his ears and nostrils with the sharp brass; but he, injured in his feelings, went about, enduring that calamity with a frantic mind’, to quote the translation by Buckley for which Housman was so grateful
Similar books and articles
Intention, foresight, and mutilation: A response to Giebel.Christopher Kaczor - 2007 - International Philosophical Quarterly 47 (4):477-482.
Forbidding intentional mutilation: Some unintended consequences?Heidi M. Giebel - 2007 - International Philosophical Quarterly 47 (4):467-476.
Ethical problems of mass murder coverage in the mass media.Clayton E. Cramer - 1994 - Journal of Mass Media Ethics 9 (1):26 – 42.
The Odyssey- Agathe Thornton: People and Themes in Homer's Odyssey. Pp. xv+163. London: Methuen, 1970. Cloth, £2·40.J. B. Hainsworth - 1972 - The Classical Review 22 (03):320-321.
Dawe's Odyssey- R. D. Dawe: The Odyssey: Translation and Analysis. Pp. 879. Lewes: The Book Guild, 1993. Cloth, £50.M. J. Apthorp - 1995 - The Classical Review 45 (01):1-2.
“A Hideous Torture on Himself”: Madness and Self-Mutilation in Victorian Literature. [REVIEW]Sarah Chaney - 2011 - Journal of Medical Humanities 32 (4):279-289.
Indeterminacy in the Odyssey- Marylin A. Katz: Penelope's Renown: Meaning and Indeterminacy in the Odyssey. Pp. xii + 223. Princeton University Press, 1991. $35. [REVIEW]M. M. Willcock - 1992 - The Classical Review 42 (02):250-252.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads