Reconciling Laughter: Hegel on Comedy and Humor
Abstract
Hegel’s philosophical system turns to a species of the laughable at three
critical junctures of his dialectic: comedy appears both at the conclusion of classical
art and of Hegel’s discussion of poetry, and romantic art ends with humor. But we
misunderstand these transitional moments unless we recognize that Hegel did not
use comedy and humor synonymously. Comedy refers to a dramatic genre with a
2000-year-old history; humor was a relatively recent aesthetic phenomenon that had
become central to philosophizing about art in Hegel’s generation. Hegel also differentiated
between subjective humor, which he associated with the novelist Jean
Paul’s eccentric excesses, and objective humor. Focusing on the surprising examples
Hegel offers of objective humor— from epigrams to Persian poetry to the
obscure novels of T.G. von Hippel—I argue that we better understand Hegel’s “end
of art” thesis by tracing ways both comedy and humor can end. By understanding
those endings, we also come closer to imagining how art can continue.