Lukács' book The Young Hegel can be read in many ways. We can read it exclusively as a history of philosophy and evaluate the soundness of its method. We can ask, for example, whether Lukács is correct in attributing a decisive role in the genesis of the Hegelian dialectic to Hegel's progressive discovery of the contradictions in developing bourgeois society, especially to his discovery of the economic facts which split that society. The novelty of the Lukacsian insistence on the role (...) of Hegel's economic conceptions provoked violent reactions from the very beginning. Alluding to the publication of Lukács' book (whose subtitle is “On the relations between Dialectics and the Economy”). (shrink)