Abstract

Miriam solomon resuscitates a famous proposal of George Engel's to classify normal grief as a medical disorder. She has two main arguments justifying such a reclassification, one based on Engel's "wound analogy" and another a "Humpty Dumpty"-type argument that 'disorder' is a technical term that we can redefine any way we please. I consider them in turn.Solomon says: "I suggest that we allow a concept of "psychological injury" that is analogous to the concept of physical injury." Of course, we already have a whole chapter of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders devoted to psychological injuries in the form of "trauma- and stressor-related disorders" (this is where the new...