The analytical method of Navya-Nyāya

Groningen: Egbert Forsten (2007)
  Copy   BIBTEX


Illustrations: Numerous B/w Figures Description: Key questions in the history of Navya-nyaya (New Nyaya) remain unresolved: when did this school of logic begin, who was its founder, what distinguishes Navya-nyaya from Pracina-nyaya (Old Nyaya), and so on. This book attempts to answer these key questions in Part I. Part II provides a translation, analysis, and critical edition of the Lion and Tiger Definitions of Invariable Concomitance Chapter (Simha-vyaghra-laksana: LT Chapter) of the Tattva-cintamani-rahasya (TCR) of Mathuranatha (16th-17th c.). The hypothesis adopted by the author with regard to the first question is that Udayana, who lived in the 11th century, is the founder of Navya-nyaya. This hypothesis is closely linked to the hypothesis offered regarding the second question, which is that the feature that distinguishes Navya-nyaya from the earlier school is its description of concepts and the structure of the world in terms of relation. Early Navya-nyaya authors, who flourished between Udayana and Gangesa (14th c.), devised specific terminology, of which delimitor (avacchedaka) and describer (niËpaka) are the most important, in order to identify or specify relation. This book attempts to illustrate the function of these and other Navya-nyaya terms from the viewpoint of relation. The main sources upon which the author has based his conclusions are Udayana s Laksanavali and the chapters on invariable concomitance or pervasion (vyapti) of the Nyaya-siddhanta-dipa (NSD) of Sasadhara (13rd-14th c.), the Tattva-cintamaÆi (TC) of Gangesa, and the TCR. Of these Sanskrit texts no scholar has worked on the Invariable Concomitance Chapter (Vyapti-vada) of the NSD in detail or the LT Chapter of the TCR. The latter chapter follows in the TCR the Five Definitions of Invariable Concomitance Chapter (Vyapti-pancaka), which Ingalls edited, translated, and analyzed in his epoch-making book Materials for the Study of Navya-Nyaya Logic (1951). One major innovation of this book made in Part II is to explain the structure of Navya-nyaya analysis by employing 86 diagrams based on the dharma-dharmin (property and property-possessor) relation, which serve as a visual aid and help readers to more easily understand the complicated structure of its analysis. The diagrams are also helpful in ascertaining how the definitions of invariable concomitance apply to individual cases and how the entities are connected in the application of the definitions. Another major innovation is: almost every sub-section of the LT Chapter of the TCR contains Mathuranatha s clarification of part of the two definitions; but this clarification does not give the definition incorporating prior clarifications and insertions; this book provides such a definition accompanied by a diagram. In other words, Part II illustrates the structure of the whole definition at every process of the clarification, which (definition) is never presented as such in Mathuranatha s text.



    Upload a copy of this work     Papers currently archived: 92,873

External links

Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server

Through your library

Similar books and articles

Invariable concomitance in Navya-Nyāya.Toshihiro Wada - 1990 - Delhi: Sri Satguru Publications.
A primer of Navya Nyāya language and methodology =.Ujjwala Panse - 2004 - Kolkata: The Asiatic Society. Edited by Maheśacandranyāyaratna.
The justification of inference: a Navya Nyāya approach.Raghunath Ghosh - 1990 - Delhi, India: Bharatiya Vidya Prakashan.
The technique of Navya-Nyāya in postulating indeterminate perception.Brundaban Patra - 2004 - Jammu: [Distributed by] Ananta Akshara Prakashan. Edited by Gaṅgeśa.
Navya Nyāya System of logic.Dinesh Chanira Guha - 1968 - Varanasi,: Bhāratiya Vidyā Prakāsan.
History of Navya Nyaya in Mithila.Dīneśacandra Bhaṭṭācārya - 1958 - Darbhanga,: Mithila Institute of Post-Graduate Studies and Research in Sanskrit Learning.
Epistemology in pracina and Navya Nyaya.Sukharanjan Saha - 2003 - Kolkata: Jadavpur University.


Added to PP

68 (#244,717)

6 months
11 (#270,430)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?