In Julien Musolino, Joseph Sommer & Pernille Hemmer (eds.),
The Cognitive Science of Belief. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. pp. 92 - 110 (
2022)
Copy
BIBTEX
Abstract
Irrational beliefs are often seen as beliefs that are either costly or even pathological and it is assumed that we should eliminate them when possible. In this paper we argue that not only irrational beliefs are a widespread feature of human cognition and agency but also that, depending on context, they can be beneficial to the person holding them, not only psychologically but also epistemically. Given that rationality is highly valued, judgements of rationality have wide-ranging implications for interpersonal relations at an individual and societal level. We suggest that a better understanding of rationality and its role in cognition can lead to a more compassionate treatment of people who express beliefs that are judged as irrational.