Art as Certifiably Good or Bad: A Defence by Modal Logic
Cultura 8 (2):39-50 (2011)
Abstract
Connections of beauty to science, whereby scientific truth informs truth about art, is denied by a Humean-Kantian-positivist tradition. Its denial of even scientifictheories being known to be true proceeds pari passu with denying any known truth in the less rigorous sciences such as aesthetics that, for Aristotle, studiesbeauty’s cause. Related to causation is a modern problem of “knowing we know”: knowledge in science presupposes a causal principle whose truth is not known when expressed as a truth-functional conditional. But by conditionals that are modal, among other things, this and other knotty epistemological problems may be resolved – resulting axiologically in claims about art that may be as certifiably true as the truths in biology, psychology and medicine that inform those claims.Author's Profile
ISBN(s)
1584-1057
DOI
10.5840/cultura2011823
My notes
Similar books and articles
Women's Fashion: Function of Sex or Social Construction?Robert C. Trundle - 2009 - Cultura 6 (2):46-67.
Social semiotics and science education.J. L. Lemke - 1987 - American Journal of Semiotics 5 (2):217-232.
On Metaphors in a Theory of Truth.Anthony Wall - 1990 - American Journal of Semiotics 7 (3):101-112.
Steven J. Jensen, Good and Evil Actions. A Journey through Saint Thomas Aquinas.Cristobal Orrego - 2010 - Cultura 7 (2):267-271.
Peirce's Demon Abduction: Or How to Charm the Truth Out of a Quark.C. W. Spinks - 1983 - American Journal of Semiotics 2 (1/2):195-208.
Representation as a cognitive instrument.Frank Ankersmit - 2013 - History and Theory 52 (2):171-193.
Recognition Culture and Comprehensive Truth. Towards a Model of Fallibility Assumed.Anton Carpinschi - 2009 - Cultura 6 (2):226-245.
On Truth, In Theory: Representation and the Crisis of Signification in Theoretical Discourse on Architecture.Amer Ameri - 1993 - American Journal of Semiotics 10 (1/2):155-176.
Analytics
Added to PP
2013-03-11
Downloads
47 (#250,847)
6 months
1 (#447,993)
2013-03-11
Downloads
47 (#250,847)
6 months
1 (#447,993)
Historical graph of downloads