The Aims of Upbringing, Reasonable Affect, and Parental Rights: A Response to Paul Hirst's Autobiographical Reflections'

Journal of Philosophy of Education (forthcoming)
  Copy   BIBTEX


In a candid autobiographical chapter (Hirst 2010), which numbers among his last writings, Paul Hirst subjects his upbringing within a fundamentalist Christian sect to searching moral appraisal. He concludes that his parents wronged him by religiously indoctrinating him, stifling his emotional development, and arbitrarily restricting his range of valuable morally permissible experiences. This upbringing undermined his autonomy and—more fundamentally, on his account—kept him from living the life he had most reason to live. Surprisingly, however, Hirst suggests that his parents had a right to initiate him into this conservative religious life, though the wider community owed him a more non-directive form of religious education to temper it. This is a striking concession to the scope of parental rights, especially in view of Hirst’s complaint that the emotional repression required by his parents was to ‘distort [his] experience and understanding of [himself] and others in ways that persisted well into [his] adult life’. Engaging with Hirst's evaluation of his upbringing, I argue for a narrower range of parental rights than Hirst–one which excludes a parental moral right to religious initiation–and provide an account of the kind of emotional experiences to which children plausibly have a right.



    Upload a copy of this work     Papers currently archived: 91,271

External links

Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server

Through your library

Similar books and articles

Religious Upbringing Reconsidered.Michael Hand - 2002 - Journal of Philosophy of Education 36 (4):545-557.
How Do We Acquire Parental Rights?Joseph Millum - 2010 - Social Theory and Practice 36 (1):112-132.
Parental rights and the religious upbringing of children.T. H. McLaughlin - 1984 - Journal of Philosophy of Education 18 (1):75–83.
Parental Rights and the Religious Upbringing of Children.T. H. McLaughlin - 1984 - Journal of Philosophy of Education 18 (1):75-83.
On the Injustice of Dysfunctional Upbringing.Areti Theofilopoulou - 2022 - Journal of Applied Philosophy 39 (5):915-931.
Etiological information and diminishing justification.Paul Silva - 2018 - Inquiry: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Philosophy 61 (2):1-25.
From revelation and faith to reason and agnosticism.Paul H. Hirst - 2010 - In Peter Caws & Stefani Jones (eds.), Religious Upbringing and the Costs of Freedom: Personal and Philosophical Essays. University Park, Pa.: Pennsylvania State University Press. pp. 155-175.
Parental Rights and Due Process.Donald C. Hubin - 1999 - The Journal of Law and Family Studies 1 (2):123-150.
How bad can a good enough parent be?Liam Shields - 2016 - Canadian Journal of Philosophy 46 (2):163-182.
Fundamental interests and parental rights.Michael W. Austin - 2007 - International Philosophical Quarterly 47 (2):221-235.


Added to PP

10 (#1,143,184)

6 months
5 (#592,531)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author's Profile

John Tillson
Liverpool Hope University

Citations of this work

No citations found.

Add more citations

References found in this work

No references found.

Add more references