American Journal of Bioethics 22 (10):5-14 (2021)
AbstractThis paper considers the responsibilities of the FDA with regard to disseminating information about the benefits and harms of e-cigarettes. Tobacco harm reduction advocates claim that the FDA has been overcautious and has violated ethical obligations by failing to clearly communicate to the public that e-cigarettes are far less harmful than cigarettes. We argue, by contrast, that the FDA’s obligations in this arena are more complex than they may appear at first blush. Though the FDA is accountable for informing the public about the health risks and benefits of products it regulates, it also has other roles that inform when and how it should disseminate information. In addition to being a knowledge purveyor, it is also a knowledge producer, an advisor to the public, and a practical agent shaping the material conditions in which people make health-related choices. In our view, those other roles call for caution in the way the FDA interprets and communicates the available evidence.
Similar books and articles
Combating the ‘Safe’ Cigarette: Ethical, Public Health Issues and Regulatory Proposals.Tony J. Cutler & David A. Nye - 1999 - Health Care Analysis 7 (3):297-308.
E-Cigarettes: The Long-Term Liberal Perspective.Kalle Grill - 2021 - Nicotine and Tobacco Research 23 (1):9-13.
Levels of Selected Carcinogens and Toxicants in Vapour From Electronic Cigarettes.M. L. Goniewicz, J. Knysak, M. Gawron, L. Kosmider, A. Sobczak, J. Kurek, A. Prokopowicz, M. Jablonska-Czapla, C. Rosik-Dulewska, C. Havel, P. Jacob & N. Benowitz - unknown
A Vaping Matter: E‐Cigarette Use in Health Care Organizations.Sally Bean & Maxwell J. Smith - 2015 - Hastings Center Report 45 (6):11-12.
Randomized Trial of Reduced-Nicotine Standards for Cigarettes.E. C. Donny, R. L. Denlinger, J. W. Tidey, J. S. Koopmeiners, N. L. Benowitz, R. G. Vandrey, M. Al'Absi, S. G. Carmella, P. M. Cinciripini, S. S. Dermody, D. J. Drobes, S. S. Hecht, J. Jensen, T. Lane, C. T. Le, F. J. McClernon, I. D. Montoya, S. E. Murphy, J. D. Robinson, M. L. Stitzer, A. A. Strasser, H. Tindle & D. K. Hatsukami - unknown
Don’T Mess with My Smokes: Cigarettes and Freedom.Luc Bovens - 2016 - American Journal of Bioethics 16 (7):15-17.
Biochemical Estimation of Noncompliance with Smoking of Very Low Nicotine Content Cigarettes.N. L. Benowitz, N. Nardone, D. K. Hatsukami & E. C. Donny - unknown
Smoking Behavior and Exposure to Tobacco Toxicants During 6 Months of Smoking Progressively Reduced Nicotine Content Cigarettes.N. L. Benowitz, K. M. Dains, S. M. Hall, S. Stewart, M. Wilson, D. Dempsey & P. Jacob - unknown
Compensatory Smoking From Gradual and Immediate Reduction in Cigarette Nicotine Content.D. K. Hatsukami, E. C. Donny, J. S. Koopmeiners & N. L. Benowitz - unknown
Rationally Coping with Lapses From Rationality.Thomas Schelling - 1998 - Vienna Circle Institute Yearbook 5:49-53.
Effect of Reducing the Nicotine Content of Cigarettes on Cigarette Smoking Behavior and Tobacco Smoke Toxicant Exposure: 2-Year Follow Up.N. L. Benowitz, N. Nardone, K. M. Dains, S. M. Hall, S. Stewart, D. Dempsey & P. Jacob - unknown
Nicotine Dependence, Nicotine Metabolism, and the Extent of Compensation in Response to Reduced Nicotine Content Cigarettes.F. C. Bandiera, K. C. Ross, S. Taghavi, K. Delucchi, R. F. Tyndale & N. L. Benowitz - unknown
No Smoke Without Fire: Harm Reduction, E-Cigarettes and the Smoking Endgame.Angus Dawson & Marcel Verweij - 2017 - Public Health Ethics 10 (1):1-4.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
Citations of this work
E-Cigarettes, the FDA’s Strategic Orientation, and Lessons From the Opioid Crisis.Jake Monaghan & Brandon del Pozo - 2022 - American Journal of Bioethics 22 (10):23-25.
Harm Reduction Ethics, Public Health, and the Manufacture of Doubt.Daniel S. Goldberg - 2022 - American Journal of Bioethics 22 (10):18-20.
Moral Wrongs, Epistemic Wrongs, and the FDA.Jack Harris - 2022 - American Journal of Bioethics 22 (10):34-37.
External Dynamics Contextualizing the FDA’s Role in E-Cigarette Regulation.Omar Gaidarov & Rachel Asher - 2022 - American Journal of Bioethics 22 (10):32-34.
Advice on Vaping in the Face of Empirical and Ethical Uncertainty.Kalle Grill - 2022 - American Journal of Bioethics 22 (10):20-22.
References found in this work
Higher Order Evidence.David Christensen - 2010 - Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 81 (1):185-215.
The Shadows of Sunlight: Why Disclosure Should Not Be a Priority in Addressing Conflicts of Interest.Daniel S. Goldberg - 2019 - Public Health Ethics 12 (2):202-212.
‘Hey Everybody, Don't Get Pregnant’: Zika, WHO and an Ethical Framework for Advising.Katie Byron & Dana Howard - 2017 - Journal of Medical Ethics 43 (5):334-338.