Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics 28 (1):31-62 (2007)
AbstractDebates about the legitimacy of embryonic stem-cell research have largely focused on the type of ethical value that should be accorded to the human embryo in␣vitro. In this paper, I try to show that, to broaden the scope of these debates, one needs to articulate an ontology that does not limit itself to biological accounts, but that instead focuses on the embryo’s place in a totality of relevance surrounding and guiding a human practice. Instead of attempting to substantiate the ethical value of the embryo exclusively by pointing out that it has potentiality for personhood, one should examine the types of practices in which the embryo occurs and focus on the ends inherent to these practices. With this emphasis on context, it becomes apparent that the embryo’s ethical significance can only be understood by elucidating the attitudes that are established towards it in the course of specific activities. The distinction between fertilized embryos and cloned embryos proves to be important in this contextual analysis, since, from the point of view of practice, the two types of embryos appear to belong to different human practices: (assisted) procreation and medical research, respectively. In my arguments, I highlight the concepts of practice, technology, and nature, as they have been analyzed in the phenomenological tradition, particularly by Martin Heidegger. I come to the conclusion that therapeutic cloning should be allowed, provided that it turns out to be a project that benefits medical science in its aim to battle diseases. Important precautions have to be taken, however, in order to safeguard the practice of procreation from becoming perverted by the aims and attitudes of medical science when the two practices intersect. The threat in question needs to be taken seriously, since it concerns the structure and goal of practices which are central to our very self understanding as human beings.
Similar books and articles
Embryo Politics: Ethics and Policy in Atlantic Democracies.Thomas F. Banchoff - 2011 - Cornell University Press.
Therapeutic Cloning: The Ethical Road to Regulation - Part II: Analysing the UK Position.Alistair Brown - 2010 - Human Reproduction and Genetic Ethics 16 (1):60-73.
Developments in stem cell research and therapeutic cloning: Islamic ethical positions, a review.Hossam E. Fadel - 2012 - Bioethics 26 (3):128-135.
All embryos are equal?: Issues in pre-implantation genetic diagnosis, IVF implantation, embryonic stem cell research, and therapeutic cloning.Daniel Holbrook - 2007 - International Journal of Applied Philosophy 21 (1):43-53.
Therapeutic cloning: From consequences to contradiction.Marilyn E. Coors - 2002 - Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 27 (3):297 – 317.
The Autonomy Axiom and the Cloning of Humans.Christof Tannert - 2010 - Human Reproduction and Genetic Ethics 13 (1):4-7.
Reproductive cloning in humans and therapeutic cloning in primates: is the ethical debate catching up with the recent scientific advances?S. Camporesi & L. Bortolotti - 2008 - Journal of Medical Ethics 34 (9):e15-e15.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
Citations of this work
The relevance of Heidegger’s philosophy of technology for biomedical ethics.Fredrik Svenaeus - 2013 - Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics 34 (1):1-15.
What is an organ? Heidegger and the phenomenology of organ transplantation.Fredrik Svenaeus - 2010 - Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics 31 (3):179-196.
Good Parents, Better Babies : An Argument about Reproductive Technologies, Enhancement and Ethics.Erik Malmqvist - unknown
“Just one animal among many?” Existential phenomenology, ethics, and stem cell research.Norman K. Swazo - 2010 - Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics 31 (3):197-224.
References found in this work
After Virtue: A Study in Moral Theory.Alasdair C. MacIntyre - 1983 - University of Notre Dame Press.
From Chance to Choice: Genetics and Justice.Allen Buchanan, Dan W. Brock, Norman Daniels & Daniel Wikler - 2000 - Cambridge University Press.
Liberal Eugenics: In Defence of Human Enhancement.Nicholas Agar - 2004 - Wiley-Blackwell.