Searching for the Source of Executive Attention
Abstract
William James presaged, and Alan Allport voiced criticisms of cause
theories of executive attention for involving a homunculus who directs
attention. I review discussions of this problem, and argue that existing
philosophical denials of the problem depend on equivocations between
different senses of “Cartesian error”. Another sort of denial tries to get
around the problem by offering empirical evidence that such an executive
attention director exists in prefrontal cortex. I argue that the evidence does
not warrant the conclusion that an executive director can be localized in
prefrontal cortex unless dubious assumptions are made, and that
computational models purporting to support these assumptions either beg the
question, or fail to model executive attention in terms of cause theories.