Body Dysmorphic Disorder: Contraindication or Ethical Justification for Female Genital Cosmetic Surgery in Adolescents
Bioethics 30 (9):706-713 (2016)
AbstractIs Female Genital Cosmetic Surgery for an adolescent with Body Dysmorphic Disorder ever ethically justified? Cosmetic genital surgery for adolescent girls is one of the most ethically controversial forms of cosmetic surgery and Body Dysmorphic Disorder is typically seen as a contraindication for cosmetic surgery. Two key ethical concerns are that Body Dysmorphic Disorder undermines whatever capacity for autonomy the adolescent has; and even if there is valid parental consent, the presence of Body Dysmorphic Disorder means that cosmetic surgery will fail in its aims. In this article, we challenge, in an evidence-based way, the standard view that Body Dysmorphic Disorder is a contraindication for genital cosmetic surgery in adolescents. Our argument gathers together and unifies a substantial amount of disparate research in the context of an ethical argument. We focus on empirical questions about benefit and harm, because these are ethically significant. Answers to these questions affect the answer to the ethical question. We question the claim that there would be no benefit from surgery in this situation, and we consider possible harms that might be done if treatment is refused. For an adolescent with Body Dysmorphic Disorder, the most important thing may be to avoid harm. We find ourselves arguing for the ethical justifiability of cosmetic labioplasty for an adolescent with Body Dysmorphic Disorder, even though we recognize that it is a counter intuitive position. We explain how we reached our conclusion.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
References found in this work
No references found.
Citations of this work
“I Don’T See That as a Medical Problem”: Clinicians’ Attitudes and Responses to Requests for Cosmetic Genital Surgery by Adolescents.Merle Spriggs & Lynn Gillam - 2018 - Journal of Bioethical Inquiry 15 (4):535-548.
More Than Just Filler: An Empirically Informed Ethical Analysis of Non-Surgical Cosmetic Procedures in Body Dysmorphic Disorder.Natalie M. Lane - 2021 - Journal of Medical Ethics 47 (12):30-30.
Similar books and articles
Diagnosing Culture: Body Dysmorphic Disorder and Cosmetic Surgery.Cressida J. Heyes - 2009 - Body and Society 15 (4):73-93.
Female Genital Mutilation and Cosmetic Surgery: Regulating Non‐Therapeutic Body Modification.Sally Sheldon & Stephen Wilkinson - 1998 - Bioethics 12 (4):263–285.
Cosmetic Neurology and Cosmetic Surgery: Parallels, Predictions, and Challenges.Anjan Chatterjee - 2007 - Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 16 (2):129-137.
Cosmetic Surgery and the Internal Morality of Medicine.Franklin G. Miller, Howard Brody & Kevin C. Chung - 2000 - Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 9 (3):353-364.
Sliding Doors: Should Treatment of Gender Identity Disorder and Other Body Modifications Be Privately Funded? [REVIEW]Simona Giordano - 2012 - Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 15 (1):31-40.
The Phenomenology of Shame, Guilt and the Body in Body Dysmorphic Disorder and Depression.Thomas Fuchs - 2002 - Journal of Phenomenological Psychology 33 (2):223-243.
Remaking the She-Devil: A Critical Look at Feminist Approaches to Beauty.Kathy Davis - 1991 - Hypatia 6 (2):21 - 43.
Parental Consent to Cosmetic Facial Surgery in Down's Syndrome.R. B. Jones - 2000 - Journal of Medical Ethics 26 (2):101-102.
ÂDo You Have a Healthy Smile?Â.Jos V. M. Welie - 1999 - Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 2 (2):169-180.
Body Integrity Identity Disorder Beyond Amputation: Consent and Liberty.Amy White - 2014 - HEC Forum 26 (3):225-236.
[Book Review] Reshaping the Female Body, the Dilemma of Cosmetic Surgery. [REVIEW]Kathy Davis - 1996 - Hastings Center Report 26 (3):42.
How to Regulate a Practice: The Case of Cosmetic Surgery. [REVIEW]Henri Wijsbek - 2001 - Ethical Theory and Moral Practice 4 (1):59-74.
Living Donation and Cosmetic Surgery: A Double Standard in Medical Ethics?Giuliano Testa, Erica Carlisle, Mary Simmerling & Peter Angelos - 2012 - Journal of Clinical Ethics 23 (2):110.
Women and the Knife: Cosmetic Surgery and the Colonization of Women's Bodies.Kathryn Pauly Morgan - 1991 - Hypatia 6 (3):25 - 53.
The Phenomenology of Body Dysmorphic Disorder: A Sartrean Analysis.U. K. Morris - - 2003 - In Bill Fulford, Katherine Morris, John Z. Sadler & Giovanni Stanghellini (eds.), Nature and Narrative: An Introduction to the New Philosophy of Psychiatry. Oxford University Press.