Journal of Medical Ethics 45 (12):830-831 (2019)

Mathias Barra
Akershus University Hospital
In a recent paper— The disvalue of death in the global burden of disease 1—we question the commensurability of the two components of the disability-adjusted life year — years lived with disability and years of life lost —and offer a tentative solution to this problem. In an exciting and constructive reply— Is consistency overrated? 2—philosopher S Andrew Schroeder argues that our concern about the DALY may be missing the mark by accepting the DALY as what he refers to as an index reflecting nothing ‘beyond the importance we place in each ’. According to Schroeder, our consistency requirement is then made redundant. Recall our main argument: the DALY is the arithmetical sum of two components, YLDs and YLLs. The YLDs represents the individual disease burden that occurs while we are alive, while YLLs represents the individual disease burden resulting from our death. ‘Death’, in this context, is not the process of dying, which happens within life and which is captured by YLDs, but rather the incidence in which the life of a person has ended. Understood this way, the DALY is the aggregate of life and death, and we argue that these are incommensurables. Why are YLDs and YLLs incommensurables? In our article, we present several reasons for this. Briefly, YLDs measure disease burden that happens to an individual, whether it be painful experiences or loss of function. YLDs have a duration and are usually something we experience, such as pain. YLLs, on the other hand, are instantly generated when the life of that individual has expired. We do not experience YLLs, and they happen where we are not. When YLLs are generated, the life in question has already ended. On a secular account, death is the irreversible cessation of the mind and the senses, and …
Keywords No keywords specified (fix it)
Categories (categorize this paper)
DOI 10.1136/medethics-2019-105662
Edit this record
Mark as duplicate
Export citation
Find it on Scholar
Request removal from index
Revision history

Download options

PhilArchive copy

Upload a copy of this paper     Check publisher's policy     Papers currently archived: 68,916
Through your library

References found in this work BETA

Which Values Should Be Built Into Economic Measures?S. Andrew Schroeder - 2019 - Economics and Philosophy 35 (3):521-536.
Is Consistency Overrated?S. Andrew Schroeder - 2018 - Journal of Medical Ethics 44 (3):199-200.

Add more references

Citations of this work BETA

No citations found.

Add more citations

Similar books and articles

Happiness is Overrated.Raymond Angelo Belliotti - 2003 - Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.
The Consistency Strength of an Infinitary Ramsey Property.George Kafkoulis - 1994 - Journal of Symbolic Logic 59 (4):1158-1195.
Consistency Defaults.Paolo Liberatore - 2007 - Studia Logica 86 (1):89-110.
Measuring Inconsistency.Kevin Knight - 2002 - Journal of Philosophical Logic 31 (1):77-98.
Is Consistency Overrated?S. Andrew Schroeder - 2018 - Journal of Medical Ethics 44 (3):199-200.
Possibility is Not Consistency.Alexander R. Pruss - 2015 - Philosophical Studies 172 (9):2341-2348.
A Consistency Challenge for Moral and Religious Beliefs.Scott Aikin - 2009 - Teaching Philosophy 32 (2):127-151.
Is a Good Will Overrated?Thomas E. Hill - 1995 - Midwest Studies in Philosophy 20 (1):299-317.
Preparedness Was Overrated.Jd Burns & Jc Malone - 1988 - Bulletin of the Psychonomic Society 26 (6):509-510.


Added to PP index

Total views
4 ( #1,273,094 of 2,497,979 )

Recent downloads (6 months)
1 ( #428,301 of 2,497,979 )

How can I increase my downloads?


My notes