Polis 24 (1):134-153 (
2007)
Copy
BIBTEX
Abstract
The first section of this article examines Jacques Derrida's essay 'Plato's Pharmacy', specifically his discussion of the ancient Greek word for drug, pharmakon. It is argued that the rhetorical force of Derrida's essay has led to the mistaken impression that he and more importantly Plato understood pharmakon to have two possible meanings: remedy or poison. In the second section a number of Platonic and other ancient Greek texts are used to demonstrate that pharmakon signified several additional things, such as painters pigment, magical talisman, cosmetic, and mind-altering substance. The final section builds upon Carl Page's observation that the Noble Lie of the Republic is itself a pharmakon, situating Plato's Noble Lie in the context of his vision of the philosopher as a moral physician, and Plato's on-going opposition to psychological conditions characterized by ecstatic displacement