The Logicality of Language: Contextualism versus Semantic Minimalism

Mind 131 (522):381-427 (2022)
  Copy   BIBTEX


The logicality of language is the hypothesis that the language system has access to a ‘natural’ logic that can identify and filter out as unacceptable expressions that have trivial meanings—that is, that are true/false in all possible worlds or situations in which they are defined. This hypothesis helps explain otherwise puzzling patterns concerning the distribution of various functional terms and phrases. Despite its promise, logicality vastly over-generates unacceptability assignments. Most solutions to this problem rest on specific stipulations about the properties of logical form—roughly, the level of linguistic representation which feeds into the interpretation procedures—and have substantial implications for traditional philosophical disputes about the nature of language. Specifically, contextualism and semantic minimalism, construed as competing hypotheses about the nature and degree of context-sensitivity at the level of logical form, suggest different approaches to the over-generation problem. In this paper, I explore the implications of pairing logicality with various forms of contextualism and semantic minimalism. I argue that to adequately solve the over-generation problem, logicality should be implemented in a constrained contextualist framework.

Similar books and articles

The Excluded Middle.Kent Bach - 2006 - Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 73 (2):435-442.
The excluded middle: Semantic minimalism without minimal propositions. [REVIEW]Kent Bach - 2006 - Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 73 (2):435–442.
The Idea of Code in Contextualism and Minimalism.Jakub Mácha - 2012 - Organon F: Medzinárodný Časopis Pre Analytickú Filozofiu 19 (suppl. 1):116-136.
Semantic minimalism and the “miracle of communication”.Endre Begby - 2013 - Philosophical Studies 165 (3):957-973.
Contextualism.Claudia Bianchi - 2010 - Handbook of Pragmatics Online.
Contextualism, minimalism, and situationalism.Eros Corazza - 2007 - Pragmatics and Cognition 15 (1):115-137.
What is Said?Andreas Stokke & Anders J. Schoubye - 2016 - Noûs 50 (4):759-793.


Added to PP

320 (#41,326)

6 months
65 (#24,584)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author's Profile

Guillermo Del Pinal
University of Massachusetts, Amherst

Citations of this work

Language Logicality: New Evidence in Favour of the Rescale Approach?Giada Coleschi - 2023 - Kriterion – Journal of Philosophy 37 (1):1-18.

Add more citations