Journal of Ancient Philosophy 10 (1):26-58 (2016)
AbstractAgainst the background of a conventionalist theory, and staged as a defense of a naturalistic notion of names and naming, the critique of language developed in Plato’s Cratylus does not only propose that human language, in contrast to the language of the gods, is bound to the realm of myth and lie. The dialogue also concludes by offering a set of reasons to think that knowledge of reality is not within the reach of our words. Interpretations of the dialogue’s long etymological sections often neglect this critique and tend to end up with an overly optimistic assessment of the theory of language on offer. In the light of one of the dialogue’s central etymological accounts, Socrates’ etymology of the name Hermes, this paper discusses two recent and influential versions of such a view: David Sedley’s theory of onomatopoetic encapsulation and Franco Trivigno’s qualified referentialism. It argues that the complex relation between language and reality expressed in the Cratylus cannot be exhaustively captured by either of these theories because Plato considers all names to be semantically underdetermined until they are put to use. It suggests that Plato rather works with a functionalistic notion of names and naming, and that the dialogue’s account of natural and correct naming is to be understood in these terms.
Similar books and articles
Proclus ' commentary on the cratylus in context: Ancient theories of language and naming (review).Taneli Kukkonen - 2009 - Journal of the History of Philosophy 47 (2):pp. 309-310.
Logos as the Message from the Gods.Sean D. Kirkland - 2007 - Bochumer Philosophisches Jahrbuch Fur Antike Und Mittelalter 12 (1):1-14.
The Cratylus: Plato’s Critique of Naming.Richard J. Ketchum - 1995 - Ancient Philosophy 15 (1):211-214.
Socrates Agonistes: The Case of the Cratylus Etymologies.Rachel Barney - 1998 - Oxford Studies in Ancient Philosophy 16:63-98.
The Correctness of Names [Microform] Plato's Own Nature Thesis in the Cratylus. --.Michael D. Palmer - 1985 - University Microfilms International.
Plato's Cratylus: The Comedy of Language.S. Montgomery Ewegen - 2013 - Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
What's in a Name: An Interpretation of Plato's "Cratylus".Donald James Mclean - 1991 - Dissertation, University of Waterloo (Canada)
False Names, Demonstratives and the Refutation of Linguistic Naturalism in Plato's "Cratylus" 427 d1-431c3.Imogen Smith - 2008 - Phronesis 53 (2):125-151.
Teratology and Truth: Socrates' Investigation of Poetic Names in the "Cratylus".Ashley Elliott Pryor - 2001 - Dissertation, The Pennsylvania State University
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
Citations of this work
No citations found.
References found in this work
Dialectic and Dialogue: Plato's Practice of Philosophical Inquiry.Francisco J. González - 1998 - Northwestern University Press.