Medicine’s metaphysical morass: how confusion about dualism threatens public health

Synthese 2020 (December):1977-2005 (2020)
  Copy   BIBTEX


What position on dualism does medicine require? Our understanding of that ques- tion has been dictated by holism, as defined by the biopsychosocial model, since the late twentieth century. Unfortunately, holism was characterized at the start with con- fused definitions of ‘dualism’ and ‘reductionism’, and that problem has led to a deep, unrecognized conceptual split in the medical professions. Some insist that holism is a nonreductionist approach that aligns with some form of dualism, while others insist it’s a reductionist view that sets out to eradicate dualism. It’s important to consider each version. Nonreductive holism is philosophically consistent and clinically unprob- lematic. Reductive holism, however, is conceptually incoherent—yet it is the basis for the common idea that the boundary between medical and mental health disorders must be vague. When we trace that idea through to its implementation in medical practice, we find evidence that it compromises the safety of patient care in the large portion of cases where clinicians grapple with diagnosis at the boundary between psychiatry and medicine. Having established that medicine must embrace some form of nonreduc- tionism, I argue that Chalmers’ naturalistic dualism is a stronger prima facie candidate than the nonreductive alternatives. Regardless of which form of nonreductionism we prefer, some philosophical corrections are needed to give medicine a safe and coherent foundation.

Similar books and articles

How to Be a Holist Who Rejects the Biopsychosocial Model.Diane O’Leary - 2021 - European Journal of Analytic Philosophy 17 (2):(M4)5-20.
Mind-Body Dualism: A Critique From a Health Perspective.Neeta Mehta - 2011 - Mens Sana Monographs 9 (1):202-209.
It's All About Me.Donna Dickenson - 2013 - New Scientist 2934.
Ethische Aspekte von Public Health.Alena Buyx & Stefan Huster - 2010 - Ethik in der Medizin 22 (3):175-177.
A Confusion with Consequences.Katharina Neges - 2019 - Constructivist Foundations 15 (2):178-180.
Transplant Medicine as Borderline Medicine.Volker H. Schmidt - 2003 - Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 6 (3):319-321.
Jenseits der Therapie.Dr med Alena M. Buyx - 2006 - Ethik in der Medizin 18 (3):267-272.
Sterben in Würde.Klaus Gahl - 2008 - Ethik in der Medizin 20 (1):3-5.


Added to PP

89 (#136,389)

6 months
28 (#39,367)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Citations of this work

How to Be a Holist Who Rejects the Biopsychosocial Model.Diane O’Leary - 2021 - European Journal of Analytic Philosophy 17 (2):(M4)5-20.

Add more citations