Criminal Law and Philosophy 13 (3):515-544 (2019)
AbstractHow does the human animal who thinks and loves relate to criminal justice? This essay takes up the idea of a moral psychology of guilt promoted by Bernard Williams and Herbert Morris. Against modern liberal society’s ‘peculiar’ legal morality of voluntary responsibility, it pursues Morris’s ethical account of guilt as involving atonement and identification with others. Thinking of guilt in line with Morris, and linking it with the idea of moral psychology, takes the essay to Freud’s metapsychology in Civilization and Its Discontents. Two conflicting routes to guilt are noted in Freud, one involving internalisation of external anger to suppress destructive instincts, the other loving identification with others in the process of self-formation. This second route is developed through the psychoanalytic thought of Hans Loewald and Jonathan Lear. Following Loewald, the moral psychology of self-formation makes loving identification with others the root of responsibility, guilt and atonement. Following Lear, the moral psychology of guilt developed on these lines renders psychoanalysis part of a broadly understood philosophical project following Aristotelian and Socratic principles. Underlying Morris’s account of guilt is the possibility of ‘prospective identification’, understood as the moral and psychological ground of guilt and reconciliation. This is the rational core of criminal justice, which maintains an uneasy relationship with law’s ‘peculiar’ morality.
Similar books and articles
On Guilt and Innocence: Essays in Legal Philosophy and Moral Psychology.G. J. Warnock - 1980 - Noûs 14 (1):134-135.
Shame, Guilt and Morality.Fabrice Teroni & Otto Bruun - 2011 - Journal of Moral Philosophy 8 (2):223-245.
Guilt and Child Soldiers.Krista K. Thomason - 2016 - Ethical Theory and Moral Practice 19 (1):115-127.
Love and justice : can we flourish without addressing the past?Alan Norrie - 2018 - Journal of Critical Realism 17 (1):17-33.
Love and justice: can we flourish without addressing the past?Alan Norrie - 2018 - Journal of Critical Realism 17 (1):17-33.
Collective guilt and collective guilt feelings.Margaret Gilbert - 2002 - The Journal of Ethics 6 (2):115-143.
Transcendental Guilt: Reflections on Ethical Finitude.Sami Pihlström - 2011 - Lexington Books.
Moral rules, the moral sentiments, and behavior: Toward a theory of an optimal moral system.Louis Kaplow & Steven Shavell - manuscript
On Guilt and Innocence: Essays in Legal Philosophy and Moral Psychology.Herbert Morris - 1979 - University of California Press.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
Citations of this work
Realism, dialectic, justice and law: an interview with Alan Norrie.Alan Norrie & Jamie Morgan - 2021 - Journal of Critical Realism 20 (1):98-122.
The flesh made word: critical realism, psychoanalysis, and the ontology of love.Alan Norrie - 2020 - Journal of Critical Realism 19 (4):341-361.
Beyond Persecutory Impulse and Humanising Trace: On Didier Fassin’s The Will to Punish.Alan Norrie - 2019 - Criminal Law and Philosophy 13 (4):681-688.
Shame, guilt and Martha Nussbaum’s immaturing process: alethic truth and human flourishing.Amanda Wilson - 2020 - Journal of Critical Realism 19 (4):380-397.
Introduction to the special issue on ‘post-truth’: applying critical realism to real world problems.Karin Zotzmann & Ivaylo Vassilev - 2020 - Journal of Critical Realism 19 (4):309-313.