Thrasymachus’ Unerring Skill and the Arguments of Republic 1

Phronesis 63 (4):359-391 (2018)
  Copy   BIBTEX

Abstract

In defending the view that justice is the advantage of the stronger, Thrasymachus puzzlingly claims that rulers never err and that any practitioner of a skill or expertise (τέχνη) is infallible. In what follows, Socrates offers a number of arguments directed against Thrasymachus’ views concerning the nature of skill, ruling, and justice. Commentators typically take a dim view of both Thrasymachus’ claims about skill (which are dismissed as an ungrounded and purely ad hoc response to Socrates’ initial criticisms) and Socrates’ latter arguments (which are deemed extremely weak). In this paper, I clarify Thrasymachus’ views (and those of several other ancients) concerning qua locutions and the nature of skill and ability and I reconstruct Socrates’ arguments against Thrasymachus’ views concerning skill and justice. I argue that Thrasymachus’ views are not ungrounded or ad hoc and that Socrates’ arguments are rather different (and significantly stronger) than often supposed.

Similar books and articles

Socrates' refutation of thrasymachus.Rachel Barney - 2006 - In Gerasimos Xenophon Santas (ed.), The Blackwell Guide to Plato's Republic. Oxford, UK: Blackwell. pp. 44–62.
In Defense of Thrasymachus.T. Y. Henderson - 1970 - American Philosophical Quarterly 7 (3):218 - 228.
The power struggle of Republic I.Ioannis Evrigenis - 2010 - History of Political Thought 31 (3):367-382.
Doing Justice to Thrasymachus.Mark Piper - 2005 - Polis 22 (1):24-44.
An Argument for Thrasymachus.Francis Sparshott - 1988 - Apeiron 21 (1):55 - 67.
Responding to Plato's Thrasymachus.A. G. N. Flew - 1995 - Philosophy 70 (273):436 - 447.
Responding to Plato′s Thrasymachus.A. G. N. Flew - 1995 - Philosophy 70 (273):436.
Plato and Common Morality.Julia Annas - 1978 - Classical Quarterly 28 (2):437-451.

Analytics

Added to PP
2018-09-08

Downloads
3,988 (#1,488)

6 months
220 (#10,581)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author's Profile

Tamer Nawar
Universitat de Barcelona

References found in this work

The Concept of Mind.Gilbert Ryle - 1949 - Revue Philosophique de la France Et de l'Etranger 141:125-126.
Freedom Within Reason.Susan R. Wolf - 1990 - New York: Oup Usa.
The Concept of Mind.Gilbert Ryle - 1950 - British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 1 (4):328-332.
Speaker’s Reference and Semantic Reference.Saul Kripke - 1977 - Midwest Studies in Philosophy 2 (1):255-276.

View all 77 references / Add more references