Philosophical Perspectives 28 (1):173-200 (2014)
AbstractA traditional picture is that cases of deontic constraints--- cases where an act is wrong (or one that there is most reason to not do) even though performing that act will prevent more acts of the same morally (or practically) relevant type from being performed---form a kind of fault line in ethical theory separating (agent-neutral) consequentialist theories from other ethical theories. But certain results in the recent literature, such as those due to Graham Oddie and Peter Milne in "Act and Value", do not sit well this traditional wisdom. My aim in this paper is to argue that both the traditional wisdom and Oddie and Milne are mistaken. I begin by looking more closely at the traditional wisdom and why it fails (§1). Then I develop my account of this fault line in ethical theory and its importance (§2). Finally I show that a diagnosis of where Oddie and Milne go wrong follows as a corollary of this new account (§3). An important upshot will be that discussions of cases of deontic constraints would do best to focus on the account of the nature and importance of the cases identified in this paper rather than continuing to work with the mistaken traditional picture.
Similar books and articles
Responsibility, Compensation and Accident Law Reform.Nicole A. Vincent - 2007 - Dissertation, University of Adelaide
From Interface to Correspondence: Recovering Classical Representations in a Pragmatic Theory of Semantic Information.Orlin Vakarelov - 2013 - Minds and Machines (3):1-25.
Bridging a Fault Line: On underdetermination and the ampliative adequacy of competing theories.Guy Axtell - 2014 - In Abrol Fairweather (ed.), Virtue Epistemology Naturalized. Synthese Library. pp. 227-245.
Should We Draw a Line Between Business And Ethics?Yusuke Kaneko - 2011 - The ACERP 2011 Conference Proceedings 1 (1):195-208.
Faultless or Disagreeement.Andrea Iacona - 2008 - In Manuel Garcia-Carpintero & Max Kolbel (eds.), Relative Truth. Oxford University Press. pp. 287.
Men and Women Behaving Badly: Is Fault Dead in English Family Law?Andrew Bainham - 2001 - Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 21 (2):219-238.
Equal Freedom: selected Tanner lectures on human values.Stephen L. Darwall - 1995 - University of Michigan Press.
Contractual Liability: for Fault or Strict?Simona Selelionytė-Drukteinienė - 2011 - Jurisprudencija: Mokslo darbu žurnalas 18 (4):1417-1441.
Enhancing ethical decision support methods: clarifying the solution space with line drawing.D. Gotterbarn - 2007 - Acm Sigcas Computers and Society 37 (2):53-63.
Fractured pedagogy : the design and implementation fault line in architectural knowledge : a conceptual and historical analysis.Francis Carter - unknown
How Theories of Perception Deploy the Line: Reconfiguring Students' Bodies Through Topo‐Philosophy.Elizabeth de Freitas - 2014 - Educational Theory 64 (3):285-301.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
Citations of this work
Consequentialism and the Agent’s Point of View.Nathan Robert Howard - 2022 - Ethics 132 (4):787-816.
The fundamental reason for reasons fundamentalism.Mark Schroeder - 2021 - Philosophical Studies 178 (10):3107-3127.