Exploration and exploitation of Victorian science in Darwin’s reading notebooks

Cognition 159:117-126 (2017)
  Copy   BIBTEX

Abstract

Search in an environment with an uncertain distribution of resources involves a trade-off between exploitation of past discoveries and further exploration. This extends to information foraging, where a knowledge-seeker shifts between reading in depth and studying new domains. To study this decision-making process, we examine the reading choices made by one of the most celebrated scientists of the modern era: Charles Darwin. From the full-text of books listed in his chronologically-organized reading journals, we generate topic models to quantify his local (text-to-text) and global (text-to-past) reading decisions using Kullback-Liebler Divergence, a cognitively-validated, information-theoretic measure of relative surprise. Rather than a pattern of surprise-minimization, corresponding to a pure exploitation strategy, Darwin’s behavior shifts from early exploitation to later exploration, seeking unusually high levels of cognitive surprise relative to previous eras. These shifts, detected by an unsupervised Bayesian model, correlate with major intellectual epochs of his career as identified both by qualitative scholarship and Darwin’s own self-commentary. Our methods allow us to compare his consumption of texts with their publication order. We find Darwin’s consumption more exploratory than the culture’s production, suggesting that underneath gradual societal changes are the explorations of individual synthesis and discovery. Our quantitative methods advance the study of cognitive search through a framework for testing interactions between individual and collective behavior and between short- and long-term consumption choices. This novel application of topic modeling to characterize individual reading complements widespread studies of collective scientific behavior.

Similar books and articles

The Darwin reading notebooks.Peter J. Vorzimmer - 1977 - Journal of the History of Biology 10 (1):107-153.
The Darwin Reading Notebooks (1838-1860).Peter J. Vorzimmer - 1977 - Journal of the History of Biology 10 (1):107 - 153.
Darwin's science and Victorian philosophy of science.David L. Hull - 2003 - In J. Hodges & Gregory Radick (eds.), The Cambridge Companion to Darwin. Cambridge University Press. pp. 168--191.
Deconstructing Darwin: Evolutionary theory in context.David L. Hull - 2005 - Journal of the History of Biology 38 (1):137-152.
Darwin’s place in the history of thought: A reevaluation.Robert J. Richards - 2009 - Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 106 (Supplement 1):10056-10060.
Darwin’s Methodological Evolution.James G. Lennox - 2005 - Journal of the History of Biology 38 (1):85-99.
«La bellezza è un sentimento istintivo». L'estetico nei Notebooks darwiniani.Lorenzo Bartalesi - 2012 - Aisthesis: Pratiche, Linguaggi E Saperi Dell’Estetico 5.
Review of the Cambridge Companion to Darwin. [REVIEW]John S. Wilkins - 2010 - Reports of the National Center for Science Education.

Analytics

Added to PP
2017-06-26

Downloads
197 (#65,454)

6 months
51 (#25,971)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author Profiles

Colin Allen
University of Pittsburgh
Simon DeDeo
Carnegie Mellon University

References found in this work

Expectation-based syntactic comprehension.Roger Levy - 2008 - Cognition 106 (3):1126-1177.
Marcus Aurelius: Meditations, Books 1-6.Marcus Aurelius - 2013 - Oxford, United Kingdom: Oxford University Press.
A Mathematical Theory of Communication.Claude E. Shannon - 1948 - Bell System Technical Journal 27:379–423.

View all 13 references / Add more references