Johann Georg Hamann und Friedrich Heinrich Jacobi [Book Review]
Review of Metaphysics 20 (2):370-371 (1966)
AbstractThis is a complicated and ingenious study of one of the famous friendships of German intellectual history. Miss Knoll's aim is not so much to analyze philosophical ideas as to find the major structural elements of this highly emotional literary friendship between Hamann and Jacobi. The book begins with a short review of Hegel's and Dilthey's treatment of the "subject," Hamann-Jacobi. The author objects to these treatments which, like practically all other students of the question viewed the letters from an exclusively philosophical and speculative viewpoint, and never tackled the deeply personal structure of this metaphysical-religious correspondence. This is exactly what the present author attempts to do. The analysis of Hamann's highly complex reactions to Jacobi's famous book on Lessing's Spinozism reveals to us how strongly and on how many levels the "magician of the North" criticized Jacobi—and through him any attempt to combat the Enlightenment which does not reject it in integro. On the other hand Hamann continuously sent his manuscripts to Jacobi to be read and criticized, and, in this way, he sought to help the latter to grow by making him contribute to works of a dimension and depth completely alien to his own thought But the destiny of Hamann was to be misunderstood by Jacobi, and this misunderstanding was recognized and corrected only by Schelling. Though H. Fuhrmans has already forcefully pointed out what Schelling owed to Hamann, the present book is the first to do justice to Schelling's Hamann-interpretation, until now entirely overshadowed by that of Hegel.—M. J. V.
Similar books and articles
Hamann, Nietzsche, and Wittgenstein on the language of philosophers.Jonathan Gray - 2012 - In Lisa Marie Anderson (ed.), Hamann and the Tradition. Northwestern University Press.
Johann Georg Hamann, Briefwechsel (1751-1788): Lexicological System and Concordances on Cd-Rom with Thesaurus.Angelo Pupi & Johann Georg Hamann (eds.) - 2001 - L.S. Olschki.
Friedrich Heinrich Jacobi: Ein Wendepunkt der Geistigen Bildung der Zeit.Walter Jaeschke & Birgit Sandkaulen-Bock (eds.) - 2004 - Meiner.
Aesthetica in nuce: métacritique du purisme de la raison pure et autres textes.Johann Georg Hamann - 2001 - Vrin.
Über Die Lehre Des Spinoza in Briefen an Den Herrn Moses Mendelssohn.Friedrich Heinrich Jacobi - 1789 - Tredition Classics.
Werke, Bd. 4, 1: Kleine Schriften I: 1771-1783.Friedrich Heinrich Jacobi, Mark-Georg Dehrmann, Catia Goretzki & Walter Jaeschke - 2008 - Rivista di Storia Della Filosofia 63 (2):387.
Novalis und Jacobi-Vom Gefühl des Entzugs und Entzug des Gefühls.Oliver Koch - 2004 - In Walter Jaeschke & Birgit Sandkaulen-Bock (eds.), Friedrich Heinrich Jacobi: Ein Wendepunkt der Geistigen Bildung der Zeit. Meiner.
Johann Georg Hamann - ein Sokrates des 18. Jahrhunderts.Till Kinzel - 2005 - Cultura 2 (2):172-183.
Friedrich Heinrich Jacobi.Author unknown - 2001 - Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads