International Letters of Social and Humanistic Sciences 74:16-25 (2016)
AbstractPublication date: 30 November 2016 Source: Author: Mahshid Mirmasoomi King Lear is one of the political tragedies of Shakespeare in which the playwright censures Lear's hamartia wrecking havoc not only upon people's lives but bringing devastation on his own kindred. Shakespeare castigates Lear's wrath, sense of superiority, and misjudgments which lead to catastrophic consequences. In Death of Yazdgerd, an anti-authoritarian play, Bahram Beyzayie, the well-known Persiaian tragedian, also depicts the hamartia of King Yazdgerd III whose pride and unjust treatment of people end in devastation. By demonstrating such defective and reprehensible tragic heroes, both playwrights set at providing audience with an anti-heroic representation of the kings and also shattering the common god-like heroism attributed to hero kings. Bearing in mind the political instability of England after the succession of James I, Shakespeare avails himself of such anti-heroic representation to forewarn those monarchs incapable of maintaining a balance between their judgments and the society's need for a genuine authority. In a similar fashion, Beyzayie narrates the true historical event of a Persian king whose improper exercise of authority, withdrawal from battle, and an ultimate escape leave people helpless against the invasion of Arabs. The article initially aims to discuss the concept of hamartia within the tragedies based on Aristotle's definition of hamartia and golden mean; by defining the nature of the kings' unforgivable errors and their extremely imbalanced temperament, the paper demonstrates how such ignoble failure relegates the hero kings to anti-heroes whose punishment equals their mistakes. Contrary to Aristotle’s idea, the article also elucidates how Shakespeare and Beyzaie have caused the audiences’ catharsis of emotion not through fear and pity but through the creation of a sense of justice by portraying characters who deserve their ultimate downfall.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
References found in this work
Brecht's Criticisms of Aristotle's Aesthetics of Tragedy.Angela Curran - 2001 - Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism 59 (2):167–184.
Citations of this work
No citations found.
Similar books and articles
Law and Love the Trials of King Lear.Paul W. Kahn & Professor Paul W. Kahn - 2000 - Yale University Press.
Shakespeare's "King Lear" with "the Tempest": The Discovery of Nature and the Shakespearean Recovery of Classical Natural Right.Mark Allen Mcdonald - 1997 - Dissertation, University of Dallas
The Exterior and the Interior a Renaissance Theme in King Lear.Yoshiko Nagata - 1990 - Renaissance Institute, Sophia University.
Leon Harold Craig, Of Philosophers and Kings: Political Philosophy in Shakespeare's Macbeth and King Lear Reviewed By.William Mathie - 2003 - Philosophy in Review 23 (1):10-12.
A Cognitive Interpretation of Aristotle’s Concepts of Catharsis and Tragic Pleasure.Mahesh Ananth - 2014 - International Journal of Art and Art History 2 (2).
The Eschatology of Shakespeare's Great Tragedies: Ultimate Reality and Meaning in Hamlet, Othello, King Lear, and MacBeth.Albert C. Labriola - 2000 - Ultimate Reality and Meaning 23 (4):319-338.
King Lear and the Naked Truth: Rethinking the Language of Religion and Resistance.Judy Kronenfeld - 1998 - Duke University Press.
"Like Monsters of the Deep": Transworld Depravity and King Lear. [REVIEW]Sean Benson - 2013 - Philosophy and Literature 37 (2):314-329.
Catharsis and Moral Therapy I: A Platonic Account. [REVIEW]Jan Helge Solbakk - 2005 - Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 9 (2):141-153.
Wisdom and Fortune: The Education of the Prince in Shakespeare's King Lear.Joseph Alulis - 1994 - Interpretation 21 (3):373-390.
Shakespeare's Cosmology.Alan Scott Weber - 1996 - Dissertation, State University of New York at Binghamton
Resolution, Catharsis, Culture: As You Like It.Gene Fendt - 1995 - Philosophy and Literature 19 (2):248-260.
A King Lear of the Debtors 'Prison: Dickens and Shakespeare on Mortal Shame'.Welsh Alexander - 2003 - Social Research: An International Quarterly 70 (4).