Action-based versus cognitivist perspectives on socio-cognitive development: culture, language and social experience within the two paradigms
Synthese 197 (12):5511-5537 (2020)
AbstractContemporary research on mindreading or theory of mind has resulted in three major findings: There is a difference in the age of passing of the elicited-response false belief task and its spontaneous–response version; 15-month-olds pass the latter while the former is passed only by 4-year-olds. Linguistic and social factors influence the development of the ability to mindread in many ways. There are cultures with folk psychologies significantly different from the Western one, and children from such cultures tend to show different timetables of mindreading development. The traditional accounts of the data are nativism, rational constructivism, and two-systems theory. In this paper, we offer criticism of these traditional cognitivist accounts and explore an alternative, action-based framework. We argue that even though they all seem to explain the above empirical data, there are other, theoretical reasons why their explanations are untenable. Specifically, we discuss the problem of foundationalism and the related problem of innateness. Finally, we explore an alternative, action-based framework that avoids these theoretical limitations and offer an interpretation of the empirical data from that perspective.
Similar books and articles
A Simple Explanation of Apparent Early Mindreading: Infants’ Sensitivity to Goals and Gaze Direction.Marco Fenici - 2015 - Phenomenology and the Cognitive Sciences 14 (3):497-515.
Perceptual Access Reasoning: Developmental Stage or System 1 Heuristic?Joseph Hedger - 2016 - Phenomenology and the Cognitive Sciences 15 (2):207-226.
Interpretation Based on Richness of Experience: Theory Development From a Social-Constructivist Perspective.Arlene S. Walker-Andrews & Judith A. Hudson - 2004 - Behavioral and Brain Sciences 27 (1):128-129.
The Concept of Simulation in Control-Theoretic Accounts of Motor Control and Action Perception.Mitchell Herschbach - 2008 - In B. C. Love, K. McRae & V. M. Sloutsky (eds.), Proceedings of the 30th Annual Conference of the Cognitive Science Society. Cognitive Science Society. pp. 315--20.
What’s so Special About Interaction in Social Cognition?Julius Schönherr - 2017 - Review of Philosophy and Psychology 8 (2):181-198.
Narratives, Culture, and Folk Psychology.Anika Fiebich - 2016 - Phenomenology and the Cognitive Sciences 15 (1):135-149.
Action Understanding in Infancy: Do Infant Interpreters Attribute Enduring Mental States or Track Relational Properties of Transient Bouts of Behavior?Marco Fenici & Tadeusz Zawidzki - 2016 - Studia Philosophica Estonica 9 (1):237-257.
A Comparison of American and Nepalese Children's Concepts of Freedom of Choice and Social Constraint.Nadia Chernyak, Tamar Kushnir, Katherine M. Sullivan & Qi Wang - 2013 - Cognitive Science 37 (7):1343-1355.
Situated Agency: Towards an Affordance-Based, Sensorimotor Theory of Action.Martin Weichold - 2018 - Phenomenology and the Cognitive Sciences 17 (4):761-785.
Analyse und Kritik aus Sicht soziologischer Handlungstheorie.Hans-Joachim Schubert - 2008 - Analyse & Kritik 30 (2):627-646.
What is the Role of Experience in Children's Success in the False Belief Test: Maturation, Facilitation, Attunement or Induction?Marco Fenici - 2017 - Mind and Language 32 (3):308-337.
Did God Create Psychologists in His Image? Re-Conceptualizing Cognitivism and the Subject Matter of Psychology.Christopher H. Ramey - 2005 - Journal of Theoretical and Philosophical Psychology 25 (2):173-190.
Talk and Childrens Understanding of Mind.William Turnbull & Jeremy Im Carpendale - 2009 - Journal of Consciousness Studies 16 (6-8):6-8.
Young Children Infer Preferences From a Single Action, but Not If It is Constrained.Madison L. Pesowski, Stephanie Denison & Ori Friedman - 2016 - Cognition 155 (C):168-175.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
Citations of this work
(Co-)Constructing a Theory of Mind: From Language or Through Language?Hande Ilgaz & Jedediah W. P. Allen - 2020 - Synthese 198 (9):8463-8484.
Encodingism is Not Just a Bad Metaphor.Robert Mirski & Mark H. Bickhard - 2019 - Behavioral and Brain Sciences 42.
Pretense: The Context of Possibilities.Monika Dunin-Kozicka & Arkadiusz Gut - 2022 - Phenomenology and the Cognitive Sciences 21 (5):1107-1130.
Encultured Minds, Not Error Reduction Minds.Robert Mirski, Mark H. Bickhard, David Eck & Arkadiusz Gut - 2020 - Behavioral and Brain Sciences 43.
References found in this work
Computation and Cognition: Toward a Foundation for Cognitive Science.Zenon W. Pylyshyn - 1984 - Cambridge: MIT Press.
Surfing Uncertainty: Prediction, Action, and the Embodied Mind.Andy Clark - 2015 - Oxford University Press USA.
Radicalizing Enactivism: Basic Minds Without Content.Daniel D. Hutto & Erik Myin - 2013 - Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.