Gunk in the Third Deduction of Plato's Parmenides

In Luc Brisson, Arnaud Macé & Olivier Renaut (eds.), Plato's Parmenides: Selected Papers of the Twelfth Symposium Platonicum. Academia (2022)
  Copy   BIBTEX


The third deduction in Plato’s Parmenides is often given a constructive reading on which Plato’s Parmenides, or even Plato himself, presents us with a positive account of the relation between parts and wholes. However, I argue that there is a hitch in the third deduction which threatens to undermine the mereology of the third deduction by the lights of the dialogue. Roughly, even if the Others partake of the One, the account of the third deduction leads to an ontology of gunk, that is, an ontology on which there are no mereological atoms (except for the One). Hence, it is unclear whether the participation relation between the Others and the One is sufficient to impose the sort of structure on the Others which, in the context of this deduction, Parmenides (or Plato) seems to hope for. Instead of the constructive reading of the third deduction, I therefore offer an aporetic reading on which the third deduction raises further difficulties for the participation relation at the heart of young Socrates’ theory of Forms.



External links

  • This entry has no external links. Add one.
Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server

Through your library

Similar books and articles

Plato’s Reception of Parmenides. [REVIEW]Scott Austin - 2003 - Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 66 (1):247-249.
Ser E discurso no parmênides de platão.Eliane Christina Souza - 2010 - Philósophos - Revista de Filosofia 15 (1):87-118.
Plato and Scoon: A Reply.James W. Miller - 1953 - Review of Metaphysics 7 (1):128 - 131.
Becoming Socrates: Political Philosophy in Plato's Parmenides.Alex Priou - 2018 - Rochester, NY, USA: Rochester University Press.
Parmenides and Plato's Parmenides.J. M. Rist - 1970 - Classical Quarterly 20 (2):221-229.
Plato's Parmenides: A Principle of Interpretation and Seven Arguments.Sandra Lynne Peterson - 1996 - Journal of the History of Philosophy 34 (2):167-192.
Plato's Parmenides: The Conversion of the Soul.Mitchell H. Miller - 1986 - Princeton NJ, University Park, PA: Pennsylvania State University Press.


Added to PP

55 (#216,711)

6 months
40 (#33,737)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author's Profile

Samuel Meister
University of Toronto, St. George Campus

Citations of this work

No citations found.

Add more citations

References found in this work

Plato's Parmenides.Constance C. Meinwald - 1991 - Oxford University Press.
Introduction.James G. Lennox & Mary Louise Gill - 2017 - In James G. Lennox & Mary Louise Gill (eds.), Self-Motion: From Aristotle to Newton. Princeton University Press.

View all 7 references / Add more references