Putting the Cratylus in its Place

Classical Quarterly 36 (01):124- (1986)
  Copy   BIBTEX

Abstract

The Cratylus begins with a paradox; it ends with a paradox; and it has a paradox in between. But this disturbing characteristic of the dialogue has been overshadowed, not to say ignored, in the literature. For commentators have seen it as their task to discover exactly what theory of language Plato himself, despite his declared perplexity, intends to adopt as he rejects the alternatives of Hermogenes and Cratylus. A common view, then, has been to suppose that the πορίαι of the dialogue are mere camouflage for the hidden dogma, whatever that may be. A favoured candidate, of course, has been the theory of transcendent forms, in some preliminary version. As a consequence, the dialogue has often been seen as a precursor to the great metaphysical works of Plato's middle period such as the Phaedo or the Republic. Not so, I shall argue. My case is that this dialogue centres upon a series of paradoxes which are both powerful and unsettling. Their final effect is to attack the theory of forms, not to defend it. They are, I suggest, genuine proposals of philosophical difficulty, rather than mere artifice to disguise an idealist truth. As such, they belong, and may clearly be seen to belong, with works of the critical period which subject the theory of forms to scrutiny. Thus the πορίαι of the Cratylus have their counterparts in the Parmenides, the Theaetetus and the Sophist. I propose, then, that the dialogue was written during the late, critical period of Plato's philosophical activity

Links

PhilArchive



    Upload a copy of this work     Papers currently archived: 90,593

External links

Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server

Through your library

Similar books and articles

Socrates Agonistes: The Case of the Cratylus Etymologies.Rachel Barney - 1998 - Oxford Studies in Ancient Philosophy 16:63-98.
The Cratylus of Plato: a commentary.Francesco Ademollo - 2011 - New York: Cambridge University Press.
Right Names.Christopher Eagle - 2009 - Epoché: A Journal for the History of Philosophy 14 (1):57-75.
Putting Logic in Its Place. [REVIEW]Igor Douven - 2008 - Philosophical Review 117 (1):123-126.
Putting politics in its place.Charles E. Merriam - 1936 - International Journal of Ethics 46 (2):127-150.
Putting Hegemony in its Place.Bob Jessop - 2003 - Journal of Critical Realism 2 (1):138-148.

Analytics

Added to PP
2010-12-09

Downloads
29 (#474,441)

6 months
4 (#319,344)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?