The ethics of managing elephants

Acta Academica 38 (1):55-90 (2006)
  Copy   BIBTEX

Abstract

If humans may indeed legitimately intervene in conservation areas to let nature be and to protect the lives of all the diverse individual animals under their care, then the management of elephants must be legitimate as part of the conservation of natural world diversities. If this is so, to what extent are current management options ethically acceptable? In this article I address the ethics of the management options available once the judgement has been made that there are too many elephants in a conservation area. I evaluate the ethical acceptability of four options, i.e., the simulation of nature, translocation, contraception, and culling. I furthermore ask whether the harsh blow of culling under very specific conditions can be softened by the taming and training of African elephants. I then examine the ethics of decision making about these issues. Before I do so, two issues must be discussed that decisively influence the management of elephants. The one is whether it is ethically justifiable to fence in elephants. The second is the ethical requirements of the scientific practice that informs management decisions. In the article I come to the conclusion that all four options are ethically flawed. All four require some violation of the important injunction to let nature be and to treat individual animals with respect. However, to do nothing and allow a loss of other species violates the important goal of conserving natural world diversity.

Links

PhilArchive

External links

  • This entry has no external links. Add one.
Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server

Through your library

Similar books and articles

Elephants and people in India : historical patterns of capture and management.Dhriti K. Lahiri Choudhury - 2008 - In Christen M. Wemmer & Catherine A. Christen (eds.), Elephants and Ethics: Toward a Morality of Coexistence. Johns Hopkins University Press. pp. 149.
Elephants and ethics: toward a morality of coexistence.Christen M. Wemmer & Catherine A. Christen (eds.) - 2008 - Baltimore, Md.: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Most zoos do not deserve elephants.David Hancocks - 2008 - In Christen M. Wemmer & Catherine A. Christen (eds.), Elephants and Ethics: Toward a Morality of Coexistence. Johns Hopkins University Press.
Why circuses are unsuited to elephants.Lori Alward - 2008 - In Christen M. Wemmer & Catherine A. Christen (eds.), Elephants and Ethics: Toward a Morality of Coexistence. Johns Hopkins University Press. pp. 205.
The challenges of meeting the needs of captive elephants.Jane Garrison - 2008 - In Christen M. Wemmer & Catherine A. Christen (eds.), Elephants and Ethics: Toward a Morality of Coexistence. Johns Hopkins University Press. pp. 237.
Elephants in time and space : evolution and ecology.Raman Sukumar - 2008 - In Christen M. Wemmer & Catherine A. Christen (eds.), Elephants and Ethics: Toward a Morality of Coexistence. Johns Hopkins University Press.
Canvas to concrete : elephants and the circus-zoo relationship.Michael D. Kreger - 2008 - In Christen M. Wemmer & Catherine A. Christen (eds.), Elephants and Ethics: Toward a Morality of Coexistence. Johns Hopkins University Press. pp. 185.
Toward an ethic of intimacy : touring and trophy hunting for elephants in Africa.Rebecca Hardin - 2008 - In Christen M. Wemmer & Catherine A. Christen (eds.), Elephants and Ethics: Toward a Morality of Coexistence. Johns Hopkins University Press. pp. 419.
Zoos as responsible stewards of elephants.Michael Hutchins, Brandie Smith & Mike Keele - 2008 - In Christen M. Wemmer & Catherine A. Christen (eds.), Elephants and Ethics: Toward a Morality of Coexistence. Johns Hopkins University Press. pp. 285.
View from the big top : why elephants belong in North American circuses.Dennis Schmitt - 2008 - In Christen M. Wemmer & Catherine A. Christen (eds.), Elephants and Ethics: Toward a Morality of Coexistence. Johns Hopkins University Press.

Analytics

Added to PP
2011-04-06

Downloads
1,255 (#8,625)

6 months
228 (#9,167)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author's Profile

Hennie Lötter
University of Johannesburg

Citations of this work

No citations found.

Add more citations

References found in this work

Democracy and Disagreement.Amy Gutmann & Dennis Thompson - 1996 - Ethics 108 (3):607-610.
Headaches and heartaches: the elephant management dilemma.Ian J. Whyte - forthcoming - Environmental Ethics: Introductory Readings, Ed. D. Schmidtz and E. Willot.
Does Stakeholder Theory Require Democratic Management?Carol C. Gould - 2002 - Business and Professional Ethics Journal 21 (1):3-20.

Add more references