Abstract

This is an essay on aggravating circumstances. Rather than defend a thesis that particular things ought to be considered aggravating circumstances to wrongdoing, I assume general agreement about major sorts of aggravating circumstances; and I ask instead how they work and what their operation reveals about moral standards in general and minimal expectations in particular. In the final section of this essay, I briefly consider what can be said in defense of the commonsense principle that punishment should be more severe if a crime is committed under aggravating circumstances than if it is not.