The responsibility dilemma for killing in war: A review essay

Philosophy and Public Affairs 38 (2):180-213 (2010)
  Copy   BIBTEX


Killing in War presents the Moral Equality of Combatants with serious, and in my view insurmountable problems. Absent some novel defense, this thesis is now very difficult to sustain. But this success is counterbalanced by the strikingly revisionist implications of McMahan’s account of the underlying morality of killing in war, which forces us into one of two unattractive positions, contingent pacifism, or near-total war. In this article, I have argued that his efforts to mitigate these controversial implications fail. The reader is left stranded: to reach plausible conclusions, Walzer deployed an implausible conception of our rights to life; McMahan’s more rigorous account of those rights generates untenable conclusions. Absent new developments, it seems that the prospects for grounding the ethics of war in individual rights are poor: any theory of our rights to life that is sufficiently indiscriminate to work in the chaos of war is not discriminating enough to be a plausible theory of our rights to life. Perhaps by rejecting the ideal of the rights-respecting war altogether we might develop an alternative theory of justified warfare, which marries theoretical soundness with conclusions that we can more confidently support.

Similar books and articles

Killing in war: A reply to Walzer.Jeff McMahan - 2006 - Philosophia 34 (1):47-51.
Self-Defence and the Principle of Non-Combatant Immunity.Helen Frowe - 2011 - Journal of Moral Philosophy 8 (4):530-546.
Innocence in War.Gabriel Palmer-Fernández - 2000 - International Journal of Applied Philosophy 14 (2):161-174.
Pacifism and Moral Theory.Jeff McMahan - 2010 - Diametros 23:44-68.
Killing in war.Jeff McMahan - 2009 - New York: Oxford University Press.


Added to PP

1,098 (#8,911)

6 months
82 (#32,224)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author's Profile

Seth Lazar
Australian National University

Citations of this work

Necessity in Self-Defense and War.Seth Lazar - 2012 - Philosophy and Public Affairs 40 (1):3-44.
Associative Duties and the Ethics of Killing in War.Seth Lazar - 2013 - Journal of Practical Ethics 1 (1):3-48.
The Justification of Associative Duties.Seth Lazar - 2016 - Journal of Moral Philosophy 13 (1):28-55.
Rights, Liability, and the Moral Equality of Combatants.Uwe Steinhoff - 2012 - The Journal of Ethics 16 (4):339-366.

View all 47 citations / Add more citations

References found in this work

Killing in war.Jeff McMahan - 2009 - New York: Oxford University Press.
The basis of moral liability to defensive killing.Jeff McMahan - 2005 - Philosophical Issues 15 (1):386–405.
The ethics of killing in war.Jeff McMahan - 2006 - Philosophia 34 (1):693-733.
On the moral equality of combatants.Jeff McMahan - 2006 - Journal of Political Philosophy 14 (4):377–393.
The Ethics of Killing in War.Jeff McMahan - 2006 - Philosophia 34 (1):23-41.

View all 6 references / Add more references