Dissertation, University of Helsinki (
2017)
Copy
BIBTEX
Abstract
The study discusses the philosophy of Finnish philosopher J.V. Snellman (1806–81).
The focus is on Snellman's so-called philosophy of personality, which he presented in
his work "Essay on the speculative Development of the Idea of Personality" (Tübingen,
1841). Besides this work he addressed his philosophy of personality in his other works
and in his public lectures.
In his philosophy of personality Snellman develops the concept of personality
within the framework of G.W.F. Hegel's (1770–1831) philosophy. The concept
of personality serves as a basis for Hegel's philosophy of right, and it plays an important
role also in other parts of Hegel's system. However, he never provided a comprehensive
definition of this concept. The essence of personality was debated among Hegelians after
Hegel's death in 1831. In the course of the debate the Hegelian school split into two
groups. At the time of publication of "The Idea of Personality" there was a serious rift between
the Right- and the Left-Hegelians.
The study analyzes Snellman's philosophy of personality in respect of
Hegel's philosophy and in respect of the views of other Hegelians – mainly D.F. Strauss
(1808–74), L. Feuerbach (1804–72) and C.F. Göschel (1781–1861). I also attend to
some contemporaries outside the Hegelian School like F.W.J. Schelling (1775–1854)
and I.H. Fichte (1796–1879).
The study is divided into six sections (A–F). The first comprises an introduction
and an outline of the structure of the study. The second section (B) discusses
the historical context of Snellman's philosophy. The first subsection focuses on the Central
European debate on Hegel's legacy. The second subsection deals with Snellman's
life and his work on philosophy. The systematic part of the study comprises three sections
(C–E), which consider the dialectic of Snellman's work of 1841. This dialectic follows
the outline of Hegel's philosophy of subjective spirit and culminates in the definition
of personality. Snellman, however, exceeds the realm of the philosophy of subjective
spirit, as he discusses e.g. the philosophy of religion. He also comments on the debate
among Hegelians. According to Snellman, neither Right- nor Left-Hegelians are
true to Hegel's philosophy. In effect, his own standpoint in the debate, as I will argue,
comes close to that of the Left-Hegelians. The study concludes with a summary (F).