Traditionally, I am entitled to a last meal

Organon F: Medzinárodný Časopis Pre Analytickú Filozofiu 18 (1):5-13 (2011)
  Copy   BIBTEX


Nunberg maintains that there are cases like “I am traditionally entitled to a last meal”, as uttered by a condemned prisoner facing the firing squad, which suggest that an indexical like ‘I’ does double duty as a vehicle of singular and general reference. I argue against this claim. My position is that the sentence should be factored out into two: “Traditionally, a condemned prisoner is entitled to a last meal” and “I am a condemned prisoner”. Nunberg’s sentence is generated by means of an illicit substitution of ‘I’ for ‘a condemned prisoner’ inside the scope of ‘traditionally’. The morale is that sloppy or literally nonsensical speech like Nunberg’s sentence is not suitable as data for logical analysis of natural language. What is suitable data is the two-premise argument I put forward



    Upload a copy of this work     Papers currently archived: 77,869

External links

Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server

Through your library

Similar books and articles

Empiricism about Experience. [REVIEW]Ram Neta - 2009 - Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 79 (2):482-489.
Evidence, Entitled Belief, and the Gospels.Nicholas Wolterstorff - 1989 - Faith and Philosophy 6 (4):429-459.
Melding the public and private spheres: Taking commmensality seriously.Albert O. Hirschman - 1996 - Critical Review: A Journal of Politics and Society 10 (4):533-550.
Has a meal trigger been found?John D. Davis - 1981 - Behavioral and Brain Sciences 4 (4):580-581.
Meal-size effects on schedule-induced ethanol and water consumption.R. M. Gilbert - 1975 - Bulletin of the Psychonomic Society 6 (6):575-577.


Added to PP

29 (#410,425)

6 months
3 (#246,604)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author's Profile

Citations of this work

The non-Italian pope.Bjørn Jespersen - 2012 - Organon F: Medzinárodný Časopis Pre Analytickú Filozofiu 19 (1):58-65.

Add more citations

References found in this work

Indexicality and deixis.Geoffrey Nunberg - 1993 - Linguistics and Philosophy 16 (1):1--43.

Add more references