Murdering an Accident Victim: A New Objection to the Bare-Difference Argument

Australasian Journal of Philosophy 96 (4):767-778 (2018)
  Copy   BIBTEX

Abstract

Many philosophers, psychologists, and medical practitioners believe that killing is no worse than letting die on the basis of James Rachels's Bare-Difference Argument. I show that his argument is unsound. In particular, a premise of the argument is that his examples are as similar as is consistent with one being a case of killing and the other being a case of letting die. However, the subject who lets die has both the ability to kill and the ability to let die while the subject who kills lacks the ability to let die. Modifying the latter example so that the killer has both abilities yields a pair of cases with morally different acts. The hypothesis that killing is worse than letting die is the best explanation of this difference.

Similar books and articles

On the Moral Relevance of the Distinction Between Killing and Letting Die.Young-mo Koo - 1997 - Dissertation, University of California, Santa Barbara
Killing and letting die.James Rachels - 2001 - In Lawrence C. Becker Mary Becker & Charlotte Becker (eds.), Encyclopedia of Ethics, 2nd Edition. Routledge.
Death is Not Always the Greatest Evil: Killing and Letting Die in Bioethics.James Green - 2002 - Dissertation, Queen's University at Kingston (Canada)
Ambiguities in 'killing' and 'letting die'.Gary M. Atkinson - 1983 - Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 8 (2):159-168.
Killing and relevantly similarly letting die.Peter Davson-Galle - 1998 - Journal of Applied Philosophy 15 (2):199–201.
Killing and Relevantly Similarly Letting Die.Peter Davson-Galle - 1998 - Journal of Applied Philosophy 15 (2):199-201.
Still in Hot Water: Doing, Allowing, and Rachels’ Bathtub Cases.Duncan Purves - 2011 - Southwest Philosophy Review 27 (1):129-137.
Killing, letting die and euthanasia.D. N. Husak - 1979 - Journal of Medical Ethics 5 (4):200-202.
Frowe's Machine Cases.Simkulet William - 2015 - Filosofiska Notiser 2 (2): 93-104.

Analytics

Added to PP
2018-01-08

Downloads
2,966 (#1,451)

6 months
410 (#908)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author's Profile

Scott Hill
University of Innsbruck

Citations of this work

Violent Deaths, Vicious Preferences, and Bare-Differences: A Reply to Hill.Zak A. Kopeikin - 2021 - Australasian Journal of Philosophy 99 (1):196-201.
Animal Rights Pacifism.Blake Hereth - 2021 - Philosophical Studies 178 (12):4053-4082.

Add more citations

References found in this work

Mortal Questions.Thomas Nagel - 1979 - Cambridge University Press.
Abortion and infanticide.Michael Tooley - 1972 - Philosophy and Public Affairs 2 (1):37-65.
Normative Ethics.Shelly Kagan - 1998 - Routledge.
Mortal Questions.[author unknown] - 1979 - Tijdschrift Voor Filosofie 43 (3):578-578.

View all 23 references / Add more references