Defending the active recruitment of health workers: a response to commentators

Journal of Medical Ethics 39 (10):618-620 (2013)
  Copy   BIBTEX

Abstract

I am very grateful to the five commentators for taking the time to respond to my article ‘The Active Recruitment of Health Workers: A Defense’.1 I have learned a great deal from each of their commentaries, and I am sorry to say that I will be unable to address all their important comments and criticisms in detail. In this response, I will focus on replying to the commentators’ major objections.In my paper, I suggested that the emigration of health workers from poor countries might not have harmful effects on health outcomes in general, or may only have relatively small negative effects in a wide range of cases. Several commentators challenge my analysis. Carwyn Rhys Hooper suggests that it is prima facie plausible that the emigration of health workers causes harm, and that there is insufficient evidence to reject this claim.2 Gilian Brock3 and Iain Bassington4 argue that my paper failed to consider the full range of possible harms that the active recruitment of health workers brings about. These commentators are correct in that we need more evidence about the effects of migration, and that it may be too soon to arrive at the all-things-considered judgment that the emigration of health workers does not generally enable serious harm.Nonetheless, I believe that the active recruitment of health workers is still permissible. For one thing, I am less confident than Brock that the empirical research on skilled migration clearly establishes that the migration of skilled professionals causes harm to sending countries. There is a sizable body of empirical research that is inconsistent with many of Brock's claims. It is not obvious that the emigration of skilled workers depletes human capital in the sending country.5 ,6 In fact, there is evidence that the opportunity to emigrate …

Links

PhilArchive



    Upload a copy of this work     Papers currently archived: 74,662

External links

Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server

Through your library

Similar books and articles

The Active Recruitment of Health Workers: A Defence.Javier S. Hidalgo - 2013 - Journal of Medical Ethics 39 (10):603-609.
The Active Recruitment of Health Workers: A Commentary.Sigrid Sterckx - 2013 - Journal of Medical Ethics 39 (10):614-616.
Response to My Critics.Julia Driver - 2004 - Utilitas 16 (1):33-41.
Biological Determinism Lives and Needs Refutation Despite Denials.Steven Rose - 1999 - Behavioral and Brain Sciences 22 (5):912-918.
Response to Commentators.David Hodgson - 2005 - Journal of Consciousness Studies 12 (1):76-95.
Response to My Commentators.Nicholas Wolterstorff - 2010 - Studies in Christian Ethics 23 (2):197-204.
Five Commentators: A Brief Response.James P. Sterba - 1999 - Journal of Social Philosophy 30 (3):424–437.
Nine Commentators: A Brief Response.James P. Sterba - 1991 - Journal of Social Philosophy 22 (3):100-118.
Response to Commentators.Sue Campbell - 2005 - Social Philosophy Today 21:261-266.
Response to Commentators. [REVIEW]Tim Bayne - 2013 - Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 86 (1):223-229.

Analytics

Added to PP
2013-06-02

Downloads
21 (#537,314)

6 months
1 (#419,921)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

References found in this work

Freedom, Immigration, and Adequate Options.Javier S. Hidalgo - 2012 - Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy (2):1-23.
The Active Recruitment of Health Workers: A Defence.Javier S. Hidalgo - 2013 - Journal of Medical Ethics 39 (10):603-609.
Associative Duties and Immigration.Javier Hidalgo - 2013 - Journal of Moral Philosophy 10 (6):697-722.
Physician Emigration, Population Health and Public Policies.Alok Bhargava - 2013 - Journal of Medical Ethics 39 (10):616-618.

View all 8 references / Add more references